18 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
R Mercer's avatar

There is still a lot of anti-Catholic sentiment in a variety of Protestant and Evangelical cults. My father did not really see Catholics as true Christians... and CERTAINLY did not see Mormons as Christians.

Expand full comment
Keith Sherman's avatar

Looking at the current Supreme Court (not to mention the 'judge' in Texas) and its actions there might well be a lot of anti-Catholic sentiment (morally and politically, not personally) in the general population.

It is ironic that it is always the Jews who are accused of having divided loyalties . . .

Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

There's nothing more ludicrous than a standard Christian throwing shade at Mormons for their bizarre beliefs.

Expand full comment
Susan Linehan's avatar

Just wait till the issue of which date Easter should be comes up. Or whether the host is the transubstantiated body of Christ. Or whether salvation is by faith or good works. We already KNOW of the wars fought over such things.

Expand full comment
Dave Conant - MO's avatar

And the Catholic Church reciprocates those feelings, hence, among other things, the restriction on who can receive the Sacrament of Communion from a priest.

Expand full comment
GlenD's avatar

True, that. My wife is Catholic and has been denied communion in her home church for over 31 years. A year or two ago, her best friend introduced her to a young Catholic priest in Ft. Worth who assured her that restriction had been rescinded. It took a few months, but the Catholic church in the community where we now live does allow her to participate.

Expand full comment
Linda Malboeuf's avatar

Limbo a dealbreaker for sure. We kids in catholic school were like What? Nope

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 10, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment
GlenD's avatar

No, she just abided by the doctrine as she understood it. We live about 35 miles from the small town (founded by German Catholic immigrants in the 1800's) where everyone knows everyone else (and, presumably, everyone else's business). I always figured the reason the Catholic church has everyone queue to the front of the church for communion was, at least in part, to make sure that anyone on the "no-communion" list would be pulled aside. Even where we live now, the priest required her to sign some document before he would allow her to participate in the ritual.

Weird thing is, my baby sister (if a 65 y.o. woman can be called that) every bit as atheist as I, makes it a point to attend mass at as many Catholic cathedrals in Europe and the US as he can, especially at Xmas, to walk the aisle to get the "Holy Cookie" (in her phrasing), which she adds to her collection to commemorate the holiday and the location. She skips the wine. Not that she's a tee-totaler, far from it, but she prefers a bit better quality in her vino than the priest profers.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 10, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment
GlenD's avatar

Thank you, Max, for your response. The last thing I care or want to know about someone when I meet them is their "religion." The one thing about evangelicalism that I deem as its most despicable characteristic is its mandate to shove itself down another person's throat, and if you don't immediately "convert," well then, you are going to Hell. (Which, by the way, does not exist.)

Glen

Expand full comment
CW Stanford's avatar

Rather interesting, though not Roman Catholic, I enjoy the liturgy and ritual of the high Episcopal church, though my favorite services are the simple ones in chapel. I do not even believe in god, but I believe in a church going community -- at least one that sees love, and grace, as its only weapons. Queen Elizabeth I invented inclusion, when she declared that she did not care what church goers believed, as long as they all worshipped together. You and your neighbor are a bit less alien, and suspect, when you have common practice.

Expand full comment
Baximilter's avatar

Many of us Jews see Jesus as an outstanding rabbi (teacher) whose story was hijacked by a man named Paul.

Expand full comment
NLTownie's avatar

If Jesus suddenly appeared on earth today, he would feel much more at home in a synagogue than in an evangelical super-mega church.

Expand full comment
Douglas Trapasso's avatar

Or an AA meeting. Or a voter registration drive. Or a farmer's market. Almost anywhere except a church.

Expand full comment
Victoria Joyce's avatar

But would the synagogue welcome Him? A jobless hippie is a dress?

Expand full comment
rlritt's avatar

I think they would.

Expand full comment
NLTownie's avatar

That might depend on what form of Judaism they practise. As with any form of belief, there are varying practices from traditional to more (small l) liberal.

Expand full comment