25 Comments

Snowcrash still impacts my thinking about what religion really is. And while The Seven Eves was kind of all over the place, I certainly enjoyed the trips. Cryptonomicon is literally on my bedside where I am trying it again for the third time. Very much looking forward to hearing your discussion. And love that you are getting into book reviews!

Expand full comment

What a great episode! Thank you.

Expand full comment

Neal Stephenson is one of my favorite authors. Seven Eves was basically two novels for the price of one and really tremendous. Looking forward to a new one.

Expand full comment

I know music better than movies. Periodically, music all starts to sound the same, largely because it has become incestuously derivative. But whenever that happens, the music scene renews itself by returning to its roots. In America, that means the blues and British/Appalachian folk music.

George Martin and the Beatles introduced amazing new studio technology, which revolutionized music. It has now become normal and commonplace, and it no longer feels innovative. But other people continued performing and listening to blues and folk, so that reservoir of tradition was still there to draw on. I suspect that movies will be okay as long as somebody preserves and continues the older methods.

My friend Mike worked for years as a self-taught commercial artist, working for newspapers. Eventually, he went to college to study art formally. He experimented with old-fashioned techniques like egg tempera, casein, and natural pigments. His professors were curious and interested in what he was doing because they had never been taught any of that. Maybe it is possible to revive older artistic techniques even when they have passed out of common use, as long as they are well documented.

Expand full comment

I love Neal, but his last couple outings have left me kind of meh. Hopefully this will signal a return to his incredible form from Reamde and Anathem.

Expand full comment

I tried to read REAMDE at least three or four times and just couldn't do it.

Absolutely loved some of his early stuff -- I still reread Cryptonomicon every couple of years -- but everything after the Baroque Cycle has left me cold.

Expand full comment

Wow, REAMDE sucked me in immediately, and didn't let go til it spit me out 800 pages later.

Expand full comment

I couldn’t get fifty pages into Anathem. I can’t remember a word and it hadn’t crossed my mind since, until I read your mention.

His quote from Diamond Age about education versus intelligence is probably my favorite ever, I cherish it, but nothing since DA has held my interest.

Expand full comment

I loved Snow Crash (and Zodiac and some of his earlier stuff), but to me, he really hit his stride when he went to the long-format books. I think Anathem was the first of them, and I've read it several times, too. Diamond Age really never grabbed me, even tho it's the one everyone talks about. REAMDE is basically a running firefight for 800 pages, and is incredibly well done (and has a fair bit less of a sci-fi element to it, if that helps).

Expand full comment

I also have Atmosphaera Incognita, which isn't quite... anything but a collector's item.

Expand full comment

Stephenson bears the distinction of becoming less interesting with each book, even as his brilliance becomes more evident.

I read Snow Crash a dozen times; The Diamond Age half as many I struggled to finish Cryptonomicon. I didn’t even start on the Baroque Cycle.

Still, the topic of this emerging series is one dear to my heart, Bohr and Dirac are my heroes, we shall see.

Expand full comment

Cryptonomicon is amazing, I've read it multiple times. Snow Crash is of course incredible. The Baroque Cycle was... a slog. I bought and read them all, but couldn't tell you much about what happened. After that series, he never quite returned to the form he had in Anathem or REAMDE, both of which are incredible (for wildly different reasons). The Mongoliad was excellent, too, tho it was a collab effort. I love the premise and the first half of Seveneves, but the 2nd half falls down a bit (tho still worth a read). Haven't made it thru Termination Shock yet, but I'm gonna have to give it another go -- esp since he has a new book out now!

Expand full comment

Funny that we disagree on Cryptonomicon, I am heavily involved in implementing cryptographic algorithms, I have two DRM patents from Microsoft (given their state, that should not be read as a boast). Yet the only thing I remember from the book is using the CapLock and NumLock lights to send Morse code.

Edit: I will NEVER put a penny into cryptocurrencies.

Expand full comment

Yea, cryptocurrency is a ponzi scheme, by definition, so I'm not sinking money into that scam. My favourite bits of Cryptonomicon were the WWII Sgt Shaftoe chapters (tho the "modern day" trip into the jungle is epic and SO well written, esp the letter about driving behind the pig truck). Given, I probably don't have the technical knowledge of cryptography that you do, but I thought it was a good primer for it, esp the bits about Adam Turing and Bletchley Park.

Expand full comment

I thought Seveneves was horrid. First of all, we never learned why the moon suddenly began to crumble, but it reminded me of a Paddy Chayevsky book e.g. Altered States or Network: good premise, great buildup, and then 2/3 of the way through it just falls apart and made me feel I'd wasted time I could've better spent reading something more educational. I would not consider reading it again. The title feels like an afterthought, as if he came up with the seven Eves wondering "how can I wrap this up."

I'll give this new one a shot. But if it turns out as disappointing as everything since DA, I won't slog through the series.

Expand full comment

Let’s just agree that the fact that an author can produce an oeuvre that is so varied that it has people agreeing he’s great, but disagreeing vehemently on which of his books are treasure or trash, is pretty impressive. For my part, DA suffers the most from NS’ “awesome premise, rushed ending” tendency. Seveneves (who doesn’t love a palindrome?!?) and Anathem are favorites. Fall… and Termination Shock are probably the biggest misses, though even the latter has some interesting ideas.

Expand full comment

This veers perilously close to a "subjective" argument, which I want even less than an argument in general.

The first half dozen or so books by Greg Egan are among my favorite science fiction ever, up there with Pohl and Cherryh. Then his interesting dalliance with speculative physics (Schild's Ladder) advanced to unreadable tedium, worsened by his new fascination with Iranian culture, and I put Zendegi and Clockwork Rocket into a trash bin.

Yet once in a while he does a short story every bit as good as Distress or Permutation City.

Just as all my favorite progressive bands went pop or just lost it, I can't expect a writer to maintain the same quality all his life.

Expand full comment

I love Seveneves, but it definitely feels like a 700-or-so-page prologue to a more interesting series about the evolution of humanity. I really hope he gets a chance to revisit that world in a sequel. Might take a successful TV adaptation to spark interest.

Expand full comment

If you haven't finished (or even started) them, I can't recommend REAMDE and Anathem highly enough. Neither feels like 800 pages, since he is (was) so good at keeping things moving (The Baroque Cycle notwithstanding lol).

Expand full comment

Anathem, I found unreadable. Intellectual cock-polishing; it felt like Stephenson has had too many people tell him how smart he is.

I just read about README as I bought the new book (yay Kindle) and, sorry, but I have no interest in games, none have ever held my interest.

I have a long time friend who has been in the game industry most of his life who tells me that the big game companies hire psychologists specializing in addiction to adjust the reward intervals in their products to entice kids to keep playing, I foresee VR games where kids wet themselves and forget to eat.

In general, I'm not drawn to entertainment, I have not watched TV in 40 years and when I do read fiction I want it to stimulate my mind, not just burn up time, something that is running out for me.

If I was reading README I would be struggling with my disdain for gams the entire time.

Expand full comment

The game is just a side interaction, which I won't spoil, but it's not necessary to know much about games, other than that they have in-game currency. It's kind of a pre-crypto currency, now that I think about it. I play computer games, but none of the "gatcha" style, where it's built to keep you coming back for more so they can sell you in-game cosmetics for real-world money.

Expand full comment

I love REAMDE and it's only nominally about "video games"; really, it's about money and finances and the internationalization of commerce.

Expand full comment

None of which interest me in the slightest. I have had a life goal for years, to read and understand Gravitation by Misner Thorne and Wheeler (http://bit.ly/3BSQk6h) the authoritative tome on general relativity, and far over my head; I thought I had many years left but suddenly I don't; a sequel to a book I found so disappointing is not in the stars, sorry.

Expand full comment