Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris Lee's avatar

Most surprising -- The Bureau of Labor Statistics. After the next hurricane, I expect that the National Weather Service will fire the guy who reads the wind gauge.

Expand full comment
Jules Coleman's avatar

I am responding to the prompt: but take note-- the prompt itself makes it difficult to follow the '2/3 kind rule'

As a long time academic and then academic administrator at several 'top tier' universities, I have been appalled by the gutlessness, the unwillingness to stand on principle (if not now, when), the lack of sophisticated response, the inability to coordinate efforts behind common goals, values and responsibilities to the body politic of university Presidents/Chancellors. Of course this should not be surprising since Presidents/Chancellors are beholden to their Boards who themselves are moved to support the institutions though rarely, if ever, at the expense of their companies. Similar remarks are in order for 'news' media.

A liberal democracy depends not on voting (as a way of expressing individual preferences) but as John Ferejohn and I argued a few decades ago voting as a way of giving voice to informed judgment. Among the institutions most important to informed judgment that underlies the values of democratic self-governance include a vibrant press and thoughtful as well as thought provoking system of higher education.

Without much of a fight, let alone a unified effort, both institutions have shown themselves unable to respond to a malignant attack of disinformation (which has gone on for years now) whose sole purpose is not to get individuals to believe false claims, but to have them become deeply skeptical of the very notion of epistemic authority, the value of which depends on trust (the destruction of which is essential to the disinformation project). At the same time, they have succumbed to a 'bullying, threatening and coercive' government that is committed to replacing political authority with raw power.

The net effect of the combination of destroying institutions of epistemic and political authority is a populace reliant on a single power as the source of information and the author of actions taken in the name of us all, while marking those who exercise independent critical judgment as 'enemies' of the people. With so much so obviously at stake, the cowardice of those who lead these institutions is striking, in effect rendering them accessories before and during the fact of the likely end of grandest of all political experiments in modern times.

Expand full comment
25 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?