7 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
Amy K's avatar

Medicare is not a socialist program - socialist healthcare would mean the government is directly providing healthcare (like the NHS in the UK, or the VA).

Expand full comment
Bruce G's avatar

You're spitting hairs. Medicare is paid for by the government, which makes it socialist.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

No, I don't think it does. It might be a social program. It might be considered social welfare, or it might be any of a dozen other terms that might apply to government programs. But it isn't Socialist (note the capital). Socialism is the government controlling the means of production. Government simply paying for something isn't that.

Expand full comment
Linnea's avatar

We provide the taxes for the government to pay. I do so every paycheck.

Expand full comment
Amy K's avatar

So, in your definition, socialism = everything paid for by the government?

Expand full comment
Eva Seifert's avatar

That's the RW definition, except for the military of course. Though I suspect Bannon, et al would love a mercenary army composed of Flynns.

Expand full comment