The Bulwark

The Bulwark

Home
Shows
Newsletters
Chat
Special Projects
Events
Founders
Store
Archive
About

Share this post

The Bulwark
The Bulwark
The Mayorkas Impeachment Was a Travesty and Dems Were Right to Toss It
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
User's avatar
Discover more from The Bulwark
The Bulwark is home to Sarah Longwell, Tim Miller, Bill Kristol, JVL, Sam Stein, and more. We are the largest pro-democracy bundle on Substack for news and analysis on politics and culture—supported by a community built on good-faith.
Over 820,000 subscribers
Already have an account? Sign in

The Mayorkas Impeachment Was a Travesty and Dems Were Right to Toss It

House Republicans undermined real action on border security and made a mockery of the impeachment process.

Will Saletan's avatar
Will Saletan
Apr 23, 2024
138

Share this post

The Bulwark
The Bulwark
The Mayorkas Impeachment Was a Travesty and Dems Were Right to Toss It
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
7
Share
U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas is sworn in for a Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs committee hearing on the department's budget request on Capitol Hill on April 18, 2024 in Washington, DC.. (Photo by Andrew Harnik/Getty Image

LAST WEEK, THE U.S. SENATE conducted the shortest impeachment trial in American history. On Tuesday, April 17, hours after receiving articles of impeachment against Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, senators voted along party lines to dismiss them. Republicans claimed that Democrats, by preemptively rejecting the charges, were trying to hide the border crisis. But the dismissal was correct, because the impeachment was preposterous. It was a nakedly political ploy, more damning in what it revealed about the GOP than in what it said about Mayorkas.

The first article of impeachment alleged that Mayorkas ā€œwillfully and systemically refused to comply with Federal immigration laws.ā€ It accused him of a ā€œschemeā€ to release asylum applicants, in defiance of the law’s requirement that such applicants ā€œshall be detained.ā€

The accusation was comically dishonest. Every time Mayorkas has testified before Congress, he has explained that he doesn’t have enough personnel, equipment, or accommodations to deal with all the migrants he’s supposed to detain. He has pleaded with Republicans to give him what he needs. A few months ago, he helped a bipartisan group of senators craft legislation to solve the problem. But at the behest of Donald Trump—who wanted to preserve chaos at the border because it might get him re-elected to the presidency this fall—House Republican leaders refused to consider the bill, and Senate Republicans killed it. Now they have the gall to blame Mayorkas.

The second article of impeachment alleged that Mayorkas ā€œknowingly made false statements to Congress.ā€ Specifically, the article said he lied by claiming that the border was ā€œsecureā€ and ā€œclosed.ā€ These claims by Mayorkas are eye-rollers, but they’re no different from the self-serving overstatements politicians make all the time. President George W. Bush, for example, spoke in front of a ā€œMission Accomplishedā€ banner in May 2003, eight weeks into the Iraq War. Two years later, Bush said his director of the Federal Emergency Management Agency, Michael Brown, was doing a ā€œheckuva jobā€ on Hurricane Katrina. These were laughable exaggerations. But if they had been delivered under oath, would anyone call them impeachable lies?

Share

The absurdity of the impeachment was on display last Tuesday, just before House managers formally brought the impeachment articles to the Senate. That morning, the House Homeland Security Committee interrogated Mayorkas about the DHS budget. The committee’s Republicans hurled bogus accusations at him—claiming, for example, that he had instructed immigration officers ā€œnot to take prior criminal conduct into account when taking enforcement action.ā€ Mayorkas patiently explained that the accusations were false. His interrogators ignored the corrections and repeated their falsehoods.

There was one moment of candor, however, and it came from Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene. She told Mayorkas: ā€œThe open border is the Number One issue across America in poll after poll, and that is exactly why this committee impeached you.ā€

She was right. The impeachment was never about high crimes. It was political theater.


THAT AFTERNOON, shortly after receiving the impeachment articles, Republican senators held a press conference to capitalize on them. ā€œEveryone recognizes the single most endangered Democrat senator on the ballot this year is Jon Tester from Montana,ā€ Sen. Ted Cruz told the assembled reporters. Cruz asserted that ā€œas soon as the managers arrivedā€ with the articles of impeachment, ā€œTester turned and ran.ā€

Sen. Roger Marshall followed Cruz to the microphone, reciting a list of swing states where Republicans aim to beat President Joe Biden and unseat Democratic senators. ā€œI certainly just hope that the folks in states like Montana and Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin, Arizona and Nevada, are paying attention,ā€ said Marshall. If Democratic senators from those states refused to put Mayorkas on trial, said Marshall, ā€œwe need to hold them accountable in November.ā€

As the Senate moved on to debate the impeachment, other Republicans joined in the electioneering. Sen. Lindsey Graham said his message ā€œto the American peopleā€ about Mayorkas was: ā€œThere’ll be an election in November. This is the only chance you have to get this right.ā€ Sen. Ron Johnson vowed, ā€œWe’ll continue to prosecute this case right up until November.ā€


EVEN HOUSE SPEAKER Mike Johnson, who’s getting applause this week for risking his job to send aid to Ukraine, played politics with the Mayorkas impeachment. On Wednesday, after the charges were dismissed, Johnson predicted, ā€œI think there’ll be a reckoning for all this in the election cycle in the fall.ā€ He boasted that Biden would have to ā€œanswer to the American people in November. And I think it’s one of the big reasons that Republicans are going to have a very, very good election cycle.ā€

That evening, Cruz went on Fox News to detail his list of targeted senators: ā€œJon Tester in Montana voted to hear no evidence. He doesn’t want to know about the failures of the Democrats’ open borders. . . . Bob Casey in Pennsylvania, Sherrod Brown in Ohio, Jacky Rosen in Nevada—every one of these Democrats running right now, they want to hide from the issue.ā€

On Thursday, Marshall went on Newsmax to extend the attack. ā€œWe have people that are up for re-election here in November from purple states, senators from purple states like Montana and Ohio, who claim they’re moderates, but then they stand in line to vote like a liberal,ā€ said Marshall. ā€œUltimately, this is going to be decided in November,ā€ he predicted. ā€œThat’s the last chapter of this impeachment trial, when ultimately we go after the goose, the person that’s really doing this. And of course, that’s Joe Biden.ā€


THE MAYORKAS TRIAL WAS—as Graham colorfully put it during Tuesday’s Senate debateā€”ā€œa friggin’ joke.ā€ But the joke isn’t that the trial was cut short. The joke is that the trial had to be held at all. Republicans never had a case that Mayorkas had committed high crimes. All they had was a popular issue and a House majority that was willing to abuse the impeachment process for electoral advantage. They demeaned the process, but they succeeded in exposing official corruption. Unfortunately, it was their own.

Take a hot second to pass this piece on to a pal:

Share


Subscribe to The Bulwark

Tens of thousands of paid subscribers
The Bulwark is home to Sarah Longwell, Tim Miller, Bill Kristol, JVL, Sam Stein, and more. We are the largest pro-democracy bundle on Substack for news and analysis on politics and culture—supported by a community built on good-faith.
138

Share this post

The Bulwark
The Bulwark
The Mayorkas Impeachment Was a Travesty and Dems Were Right to Toss It
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
7
Share
The American Age Is Over
Emergency Triad: The United States commits imperial suicide.
Apr 3 ā€¢ 
Jonathan V. Last
5,343

Share this post

The Bulwark
The Bulwark
The American Age Is Over
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
1,469
How to Think (and Act) Like a Dissident Movement
AOC, solidarity, and people power.
Mar 24 ā€¢ 
Jonathan V. Last
4,110

Share this post

The Bulwark
The Bulwark
How to Think (and Act) Like a Dissident Movement
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
1,170
ā€œHow Can You Look at Yourself in the Mirror?ā€
George is furious.
Apr 3 ā€¢ 
Sarah Longwell
2,110

Share this post

The Bulwark
The Bulwark
ā€œHow Can You Look at Yourself in the Mirror?ā€
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
349
49:37

Ready for more?

Ā© 2025 Bulwark Media
Privacy āˆ™ Terms āˆ™ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More