2 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
SETH HALPERN's avatar

Don't think you can just shamelessly misquote yourself to win an argument.

Anyway, I obviously don't know any more than you do exactly how many male teenagers were the child soldiers whom you think it was a war crime to bomb but evidently not to recruit for use as combatants (or human shields) in the first place.

But given the Hamas enthusiasm for the whole Hitler Youth genre, https://www.reuters.com/news/picture/hamas-summer-camp-idUKRTX3D638/, I'd modestly guess they comprised at least 5-10% of overall fatalities. After all, Gaza has a notoriously young population to siphon into military manpower; moreover, in WW2 the teenaged Waffen SS units suffered up to 60% casualty rates.

Add another 30% who were adult male terrorists, and that's closing in on 40%. Or 14,000 dead gunmen. Which, of course, nearly matches the widely cited IDF estimate.

Obviously individuals like you will dismiss it all as Zionist tricks, but why it should be inconceivable that large numbers of Hamas gunmen would in fact cluster around the tunnels, schools, mosques, hospitals and other structures long favored by the organization and therefore bombed by the IDF after it shooed most civilians away, is best known to Hamas propagandists.

You expect people to believe that, as Hamas has so often asserted, 70% of the dead were innocent women and children, and that, presumably, most of the remaining 30% were innocent adult men. In which case there were virtually no Hamas gunmen anywhere in Gaza, and the whole war was cooked up by a cabal of Zionist warmongers and Christian fundamentalist Republicans to cover Bibi Netanyahu's posterior and usher in the End Times.

But good luck with that sales pitch.

Expand full comment
J. Andres Hannah-Suarez's avatar

Brother, you're still pulling assumptions straight out of your ass.

Who the fuck ever said that 30% of adult male casualties were all innocent? Dude, stop making up facts and worse yet stop fucking attributing statements you invented to actual people.

Expand full comment