1 Comment
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
J AZ's avatar

Ahh, the apocryphal Mark Twain quote: 'What gets us into trouble is not what we don't know. It's what we know for sure that just ain't so.'

Your discussion of the recent survey showing widely-believed falsehoods about recession, stock market averages, unemployment, and more - I felt the same hearing about that survey as when I saw 40-some percent of my fellow citizens vote for DJT the 2nd time around: sorta shocked that there are this many people who perceive reality to be so different from what I see it to be. It's almost more distressing about matters of objective fact (e.g., unemployment rate or S&P) than a value issue like commitment to liberal democracy.

Yikes.

How can we as a nation work on a problem - say, inflation - when we can't start from a common reference point about the current rate?

Mere ignorance or inattention doesn't adequately explain this. I don't believe roughly half the country has suddenly gotten more ignorant. I attribute a lot of this to the right-wing media bubble in which some folks choose to cocoon themselves, which omits a lot of positive factual information when that info favors Democrats, small-L-liberalism, or collective action through government.

Further, we have a flood of "information" through social media which is unvetted and consumed by many with little/no critical thinking. Opinion and "fact" are treated as basically the same. If someone says "inflation is going down" (factually true) that's quickly countered with "nuh-uh, I heard it's going up." Point/counterpoint, don't ask me to show my work. Besides, I just paid $3.89 for gas where last week I think it was $3.79 (as if one anecdotal item is the whole market basket of a nation).

I admit to a conspiratorial view about social media: between bot accounts and targeted messages under the guise of advertising, a great deal of misinformation is injected into our body politic by adversaries who've spent decades studying and exploiting Americans' social psychology. Our adversaries recognize the value of encouraging mistaken beliefs & disharmony. It's far cheaper than secret agents and ICBMs, easy to deliver directly into Americans' homes, and as a nation we're not even mounting defenses against it.

Never have so many known for sure so much that just ain't so. That's not an accident.

Expand full comment