Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Suz Stiles's avatar

pregnancy is incredibly hard on the body. The US already has abysmal ratings re maternal mortality and that is going to get worse with the overturning of Roe. The point that most miss is the loss of bodily autonomy for 10 months. A pregnant woman can't eat what she wants, drink what she wants, etc. And the odds that a woman is going to give up the baby for adoption after suffering that are really low.

As to other rights not going away, this is a pretty bad take. Things like gay marriage, contraceptive use, interracial marriage are all based on privacy rights, same as Roe. And Alito stress that Roe is an unenumerated right, same as gay marriage, use of contraceptives, interracial marriage. They are all going to be challenged.

Finally, states are already trying to out-do each other for ridiculous laws. No travelling out of state without a negative pregnancy test! Death penalty to women who get an abortion! Life in prison for doctors upholding their oath to do no harm! Are in 1952 or 2022?

Expand full comment
Dayne Relihan's avatar

I am a little tired of this 'I'm sorry but this is a both sides' rationalization. What was once the Republican party has moved so far to the right with it's radical behavior and tactics that a Democrat taking a position on a policy that 10-15 years ago was considered conservative is now characterized as an extremist. The absolute shattering of the SCOTUS nominating process by Mitch McConnel is the prime example. And the argument RGB could have retired under Obama so the left shouldn't complain? Wow. Yet we should ignore the galactic level of hypocrisy exhibited by the GQP pushing through Comey Barret is an off the charts radicalization of the nominating process. Oh yes, and Merrick Garland stunt, how in the hell is that a conservative principle?

As far as other rights being eroded under the cloud of this 'draft opinion', Louisiana has already proposed banning IUDs and McConnell came out with a statement that a 'national ban' is a real legislative possibility. Heer is correct.

Expand full comment
126 more comments...