5 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
TW Falcon's avatar

Woof! Very well said. It puts Scruton in perspective for me. I had never heard of him before.

Expand full comment
Midge's avatar

I should correct something, though. I wrote,

"For those NatCons who fancy themselves members of a 'resistance' against some vaguely totalitarian something (which I believe is all of them), the romance of Scruton's resistance might be why they name cafes after him"

but it's no random NatCons naming cafes after Scruton. It's "the state-sponsored Batthyany foundation", the same foundation funding the Danube Institute.

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/06/roger-scruton-hungarian-coffee-shop-markets-in-everything.html

and these cafes seem to have the blessing of Scruton's widow, who's donated memorabilia to them and attended some of their events. Prime minister J├│zsef Antall of Hungary helped found the Batthyany foundation as a private institution in honor of Lajos Batthy├бny, a Hungarian prime minister under the Austrian empire who at first lobbied, then rebelled, for Hungarian independence.

"The Batthy├бny Foundation (BLA) was originally established in 1991 by the Association of Friends of MDF 'to support Hungarian public life based on common Christian values and democratic, representative governance.' It was a private foundation, financed mostly by donations. The original idea was to develop BLA along the lines of EPPтАЩs Robert Schuman Foundation or CDUтАЩs Konrad Adenauer Stiftung."

but, after the foundation had become a shell of itself, Orban's propaganda ministry began using it as a funding conduit for Orbanism. "For instance, in 2019, BLA received 3.5 billion forints (about $12 million) from the propaganda ministry."

https://hungarianspectrum.org/tag/batthyany-foundation/

Expand full comment
Alan Elrod's avatar

Very good points, Midge. I wish IтАЩd gone into a little detail about BLA in the piece.

Expand full comment
Midge's avatar

Thanks!

Since the Pulaski Institution has an interest in place, who's doing what to capitalize on understandably fond memories of someone in a locale seems like the kind of story Pulaski could investigate better than a commenter who looked up some stuff while she was laid up with a cold. If there's enough there for a follow-up piece, we're interested.

I know the Manhattan Institute, which was supposed to be another conservative-but-liberal institution with a focus on place (the city, NYC in particular), has had problems with donor capture:

https://democracyjournal.org/arguments/think-tank-in-the-tank/

When the donor is Orban's propaganda ministry, that sounds even hairier.

Expand full comment
Alan Elrod's avatar

I imagine a follow-up piece could be done. IтАЩll be writing more over at Arc Digital in the future so there may yet be more to come.

Expand full comment