My fantasy - a Biden/Cheney ticket. Policy differences, yes, all of which take a back seat to one and only one thing. I’m a Dem and would vote for this in a heartbeat.

Expand full comment

Liz Cheney just got some karma payback. My Kevin has announced he's done at the end of this term.....oh, and Trump announced at Hannity's town hall, the he would only be America's dictator on his first day. Hannity was perplexed.

Expand full comment

I went shopping with my wife yesterday for a Christmas ornament for each of the grandkids. There was a snow globe featuring Santa Claus looking down on, apparently, baby Jesus in a crib.

'Tis the reason for the season, I suppose.

Expand full comment

A second trump term would be one giant sharpie pen. No reality would be spared. Those with actual money one imagines would be ... concerned. Yet oddly not enough.

Expand full comment

David - I did Google this. I read the Wikipedia article on the subject, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textbooks_in_the_Israeli%E2%80%93Palestinian_conflict. Thanks. It was a useful exercise.

I Googled it because I wanted to find out why this issue is as common as it is in discussions of the Israel-Palestine problem.

I find that there are valid reasons for Israelis to take offense at the content of PA-approved textbooks, and that this has been going on for a long time. I also find that there are a (smaller) number of things in Israeli textbooks that may be problematic.

However, I am mindful of two things. When I’ve heard this issue raised, it’s always been as an argument for why Israel has nobody with whom they can make peace. I disagree with that. I think the disagreement about textbooks is more than anything a mirror of the larger issues of the Israel-Palestine conflict.

I continue to oppose its use as a reason why no peace can be contemplated.

I am also mindful of the fact that fights over textbooks currently embroil our own country. I think they are symptoms of larger divisions rather than causes of them.

Expand full comment

Please don’t overload us with links to the Atlantic. Not all of us subscribe.

Expand full comment

Charlie asks why it took the UN 30+ days to acknowledge that Hamas raped Israelis.

First of all, 90% of news outlets and Western governments acknowledged that on day one. UN did acknowledge it but not with the moral emphasis you would have demanded Charlie, namely making it the sole and immediate focus of coverage in the region for some time.

Second, I'm still patiently waiting for anyone at the Bulwark, other that Will Saletan, to acknowledge just for a second that engaging in collective punishment is a war crime, and that the Israeli embargo on basic supplies since October 7 (which Israel has repeatedly proudly advertised) is a war crime.

The moral outrage from Charlie on this point as he just glosses over a war crime that is currently affecting 2.2 million Gaza civilians is astonishing.

Expand full comment

Just listening to Sykes podcast with Saletan.

The moral conviction with which Charlie distinguishes rape of Israeli women, from the actions of the Israeli government in say, knowingly killing Palestinian premie babies was a little bit rich.

I'm getting pretty fucking sick and tired of pointing out how NONE OF YOU Bulwark contributors with the exception of Will Saletan has said a single word about the Palestinian causalities. None. Not one. Charen goes even further by ridiculously stating that Israel has NEVER violated international law.

This example is the most glaring omission haven't heard ANYONE on the Bulwark mention this story even once. Not once:


What makes it even more disgusting is that on October 12 a former Israeli PM was asked about the risk to the lives of premature Palestinian babies that would come from cutting off supplies to 2.2 million residents of Gaza. His response? How dare you talk about Palestinian casualties, they're all Nazis.

Funny, I haven't heard or read about that lovely press conference from the likes of Charlie or JVL. Cause you know, Palestinians aren't real human beings.

And not once have ANY OF YOU except Saletan bothered to call out Israel for literally committing the war crime of collective punishments. Worse yet, JVL actually had a commentator on his show who called that war crime tactic "smart" with not a word said by JVL pointing out the criminal implications of that tactic (again, cause I guess brown babies aren't human to JVL).

This is getting incredibly annoying.

All I'm asking is for you and JVL to get your head out of your assesses and just ONCE acknowledge that collective punishments are a crime. And maybe treat your guests who praise said tactics as the war criminal advocates that they are.

You sure as hell play up every even horrendously vague comment that the ADL would interpret as anti-Semitic.

Can you please do your job and make a modicum of an effort to call out racism and enthusiastic praise for war crimes? Just a modicum of an effort is all I ask for.

It'd call it ironic that Bulwark contributors have such a chubby for Reagan, but this is actually a perfect example of Reaganite political policy. Reagan was all for promoting "democracy" in speeches, as long as people were voting white Christian neo-liberal capitalist. If they diverged from that, well they'd get gunned down in the streets by Reagan funded pro-dictator radicals for being commies.

As is the case here I guess. Any criticism of Israel is bad and super duper racist. Israelis literally murdering premie babies doesn't even register on your radar because said babies are brown and Muslim.

Expand full comment
Dec 5, 2023·edited Dec 6, 2023

> All the alarms are flashing red

All that Americans need to do is to vote on Election Day, and better yet, also in the primaries, and to not vote for anyone who supports the Big Lie or who doesn't take January 6th to be an insurrection.

All Americans don't need to do this, just a small majority (just enough to take care of the peculiar American electoral map).

None of this as as onerous as going overseas to fight a war, to restrain consumption or to be rationed life's necessities, to be required to work a 6-day week, to pay more taxes, to reduce the enjoyment of life in the least. It is as close to a zero-sacrifice civic virtue that is possible, that is needed.

If the alarm bells are flashing red because Americans are no longer capable of this tiny bit of civic virtue, then I must question whether there is anything left to save. The flashing lights are not of those an emergency but of a funeral procession.

Expand full comment

I just finished reading Will's column. I don't think Haley believes the right-wing conspiracy theory nonsense she is spouting about Covid vaccines. It's just that she is a shameless opportunist and will say anything to win votes including that she will support the Fascist Trump.

Expand full comment

You are aware that the Netanyahu government is as hostile, if not more so to the Palestininan Authority as it is to Hamas? You are aware that Netanyahu PUBLICLY stated that by offering to support to Hamas, over the PA, this was the best way for Israel to prevent a Palestinian state from forming?

"Teaching their children to hate Jews"? Who does this? All Palestinians? What is your source for this?

President Biden has indicated his preference for a two-state solution with the PA as the most obvious interlocutor. Netanyahu opposes this. What do you say about this? What is YOUR preferred outcome?

Expand full comment

I understand Liz Cheney is considering throwing her hat in the ring as a third-party candidate, however she qualified by saying it was something she would not do if she felt it would help trump get elected. I don't see how it wouldn't help get trump elected because Biden isn't winning over hearts and minds despite doing a heck of a lot better job than TFG. Still, I wish that if Liz would have considered this sooner as a Republican candidate. I just don't understand how running as a third-party candidate would not help trump, unless I'm missing something. What am I missing?

Expand full comment

And how would you suggest they do this?

You’re basically suggesting that their only options are to risk their lives in a revolution against Hamas or risk their lives in a revolution against Israel.

Expand full comment

"They could be protesting Hamas...."

I wonder if this collective - of I support the poor downtrodden masses called Hamas even though they are thugs, killers, rapists, and proud puppets of Iran - believes they are doing a service analogous to my generation's protests about 'Nam? Is this their, as in whatever gen X, Y, Z, or ZZ is now called, way of feeling relevant? It all seems rather obscene: they celebrating the depraved toxicant that is Hamas while we castigated the rather imperialistic machinations of a superpower. The world is not as it once was. Up is down. Fascism is democracy. Evil is heavenly.


Expand full comment

I WELCOME a Republican attempt at impeachment. Newt Gingrich debased the concept 25 years ago, so impeachment is not what it used to be, and that is genuinely sad. On the Upside, it butchered his speakership and he was shafted out of the chair shortly thereafter. Furthermore, it shut up the people whining about Clinton triangulation and it showed the House GOP to be nothing more than vindictive imbeciles who were using impeachment as a weapon to gut Bill Clinton because he was just better at politics than they were. Was Bill slime? Oh ABSOLUTELY. Could he not keep his pants zipped? Uh....duh.

In attempting to impeach Joe Biden, the House GOP is showing itself to be pathetically desperate to show that he is as much of a massive crook as the *know* Donald Trump to be. It's like they are saying "See? Joe Biden is scum...we can prove it!!" The thing is, they can't. They have zero evidence that Joe Biden is a vile crook. They can show that his son is, but not Joe Biden. They are doing this to placate that early stage dementia addled jello mold in Palm Beach, and it is really stomach churning. The republican party used to be a place of ideas and backbones...those days are as long gone as summer re-run season.

Expand full comment

Trump's potential trajectory is strikingly similar to that of Hugo Chavez, who staged an unsuccessful coup, was barely punished for it, remained vengeful and unrepentant, and came back to win an election and set up a dictatorship. The result has been destroyed institutions, a ruined country, and millions of Venezuelan refugees scattered across the prinicipal nations of the Hemisphere from the United States to Chile.

Do Americans really want to become a huge Venezuela? Where will they run to?

Expand full comment