15 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Jane in NC's avatar

I used to follow Ken White on Popehat Twitter, and when he left I signed up for his newsletter. This was one was Pope-alicious. When the FedSoc decided to invite Kyle Duncan to poke their fellow students in the eye, it's too bad Admiral Akbar wasn't there screaming 'It's a trap!!' Maybe then, the Stanford law students could have staged an equal and opposite smackdown instead of walking into a wall.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

I realize that most on here have decades of experience, but man, Stanford Law students aren't bright enough to realize it is a trap without Admiral Akbar?

I suspect that they're bright enough to realize it and arrogant enough to think that being the hero of their own story over-rides it. Or arrogant enough to believe that this speaker was just sooooo vile as to justify jettisoning both respect for their university's institutions and the belief that they would make THE difference.

Expand full comment
Avoiding Reprisal's avatar

One would think. But emotional impulse is a hard thing to corral.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

Good thing they aren't training to be lawyers in court.

Expand full comment
SandyG's avatar

Well said!!!

Expand full comment
Jane in NC's avatar

I'm stunned that nobody pulled a bunch of them aside and said, 'think like lawyers!!!'. It's clear the FedSoc set this thing up to provoke precisely the reaction they got. I just wish some of these best and brightest had been smart enough to put their emotions aside and engage on the issues. Duncan would not have been expecting that.

Expand full comment
Christine's avatar

Or just not attend? Were they obligated to give him their attention?

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 18, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

Don't doubt you for a second, but I don't run across too many here in the heartland.

Expand full comment
Christopher Wood's avatar

Unfortunately, an Agra-welfare (subsidy) recipient here in West Lafayette, IN flys a Confederate flag in his yard, not two miles from Civil War cemetery on Vet's Home property.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

Not the kind of farmer he meant. Took me a few seconds to connect the dots since I'm not exposed to the term very often.

Expand full comment
Christopher Wood's avatar

Thanks for putting me in the know-how.

That "farmer" near me is infuriating for the disrepect to the hundreds of graves of fallen heros...and also of subsequent military actions.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

Not much makes more more casually mad than the sight of one of those traitorous flags (apart from war memorials, re-enactments, etc.). Still their right to do, but I'm definitely lumping any who fly that flag (or put it on their truck) into my own basket of deplorables.

Expand full comment
Christopher Wood's avatar

It's amazing how the lack of historical context among too many of the MAGAt boobwazie pushes them to seek some symbol of their victimization, in this case the Confederate Battle flag.

My grandfather, the scion of one of the founding families of what is now Birmingham, Alabama, left in 1910 for NYC to become a magazine writer/editor after college.

Other than an uncle who moved to Texas (west Alabama) pre-Civil War, he was the only family member to leave the Lilly White culture of "Woodlawn" (still a section of "B-ham" today) because his education made him think and research about the Jim Crow South.

The irony was that because of his deep Southern drawl, he was chided and ridiculed by his New "Yawk" colleagues. So, he found greater comfort living in Harlem/Morningside Heights in upper Manhattan, then a center of middle-class Blacks.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

I just can't get past the concept of using a traitor flag for anything. Use the Don't Tread on Me flag if you want to quietly convey to the world that you are most likely a believer in freedom for me, not for thee.

Expand full comment
ErrorError