39 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
Maggie's avatar

The movie made Bill Clinton the face of "the patriarchy" and the Republican complaint is "hey, you should have made the even more sexually-predatory president the face of the patriarchy!"

Ugh. This. This. This.

Just for having to type this sentence, I think women deserve more Greta Gerwig movies, a Wonder Woman sequel on par with the quality of the 2017 movie, and a Josephine Baker biopic.

Expand full comment
Mike Lew's avatar

That first Wonder Wonder movie was one of the best superhero movies ever!

Expand full comment
Maggie's avatar

I'm not embarrassed to say: I thought it was a better WWI movie than the latest adaptation of All Quiet on The Western Front. Chris Pine's final moment's immediately made me think back to the book: "his face had an expression of calm, as though almost glad the end had come." Absolutely Brutal.

Expand full comment
Mike Lew's avatar

Watching Diana's opinion of her fellow travelers change when she saw them helping the Belgian villagers was so good. A lesser movie would have skipped that sort of character development.

Expand full comment
Mike Lew's avatar

I thought the recent version of Alls Quiet was a great Great War movie. (Sorry, couldn't resist that phrasing. :)) However, it wasn't Alls Quiet. Too many key scenes from the book (or the amazing 1930 version) were missing. I liked it movie, but it wasn't Alls Quiet.

Expand full comment
Maggie's avatar

Yeah, my husband really liked it and I was just like "this isn't the book, this isn't what the book is about"

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

Which calls to mind Starship Troopers, which I think someone (you perhaps?) referenced yesterday.

Expand full comment
R Mercer's avatar

Starship Troopers was SO far way from the book I would have been embarrassed to claim I based it on the book if I was the writer.

It had it's moments though, despite the cheesiness.

And I always thought that the Forever War (Joe Haldeman) was a better book.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

I really enjoyed both of them.

I think Heinlein would have been disappointed that the movie portrayed the government he envisioned as fascist. Seemed to me that he took great pains in the book to make sure it wasn't a fascist government, or even a military government.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Jul 26, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment
R Mercer's avatar

I both wish that it had been made and yet am somewhat afraid of it being made, lol.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

Can you imagine the uproar today if you included the part about the changing sexual mores through the centuries?

Expand full comment
R Mercer's avatar

Or the fact that humanity ends up a bunch of clones and more like the Taurans than the humanity of the past?

Expand full comment
BlueOntario's avatar

Agree, yes. Until Ludendorff turns into a monster. That didn't happen until the 20s, after the war.

Expand full comment
Mike Lew's avatar

Using such a prominent historical figure was risky. A loose analog with a similar name would have worked better.

Expand full comment
BlueOntario's avatar

Ludendorff at an early stage played footsie with the Nazis and paralleled them in some ways, although as a Nationalist. He was abhorrently antisemitic, and Gadot taking him down has some important figurative justice. But, his leadership during war was historically more significant than what he did afterwards. Politically, he was needed to appease Hindenburg while the old man lived, and even though a rival, he wasn't offed by the Nazis for "reasons" (mostly to not alienate Nationalist veterans). He's an optional lecture slide on how that Nazis came to power.

Expand full comment
Mike Lew's avatar

I appreciate the additional historical context, but it just strengthens my opinion that Ludendorf didn't belong in a superhero movie. :)

Expand full comment
EnderAK08's avatar

It was great, and I hope Gerwig gets more big movies because in addition to being a great director she obviously knows how to manage the massive budgets that come with them.

It's very funny to me that all the usual conservative cosplayers of masculinity - Shapiro, Walsh, etc., are melting down about a movie that is basically a giant masculinity cosplay.

The funniest thing to me what Matt Gaetz's wife (cursed phrase) Ginger complaining that Ken is a "low T" man. No, Ginger, he's no T man, as in he's a plastic doll, he has no testosterone whatsoever. The highest T main character is probably Will Ferrell's character, who is north of 50.

Expand full comment
Maggie's avatar

I love how the movie called people out for sexualizing girls' playthings. And the response for the Gaetz household is... to further sexualize children's playthings. From the party that loves to call everyone and everything "groomers".

Expand full comment
CroneEver's avatar

Not to mention that we all know that neither Ken NOR Barbie ever had actual genitalia. That makes them both transgenders, right?

Expand full comment
Carol Kennon's avatar

Eunichs for the cause.

Expand full comment
Carol Kennon's avatar

Sorry eunuch

Expand full comment
EnderAK08's avatar

One thing I realize as I get older is that sexually deviant behavior is much less adults consuming pornography or having too many sex partners and more "I need to find sexuality in places they are clearly not intended."

Like kid's dolls. It's fitting that Gaetz's wife is creepy in a complimentary way to him. We'll all enjoy reading the divorce stories in a decade I'm sure.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Jul 26, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

Have you ever noticed that we never see Gaetz and Butthead in a room at the same time? The giant forehead is a giveaway.

Expand full comment
knowltok's avatar

I've never seen Trump and the Great Pumpkin in the same room at the same time either.

Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

Nor Kevin McCarthy and the Scarecrow from the Wizard of Oz.

Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

You are right!

Expand full comment
EnderAK08's avatar

One of the other things I've learned getting older is that often there's no hero or villain in a lot of dysfunctional relationships. Both sides are offenders, though often not equal.

Distinguishing that from abusive relationships, of course.

Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

Gaetz was engaged to be married when the story about Onlyfans, underage prostitutes, etc. broke. She saw no problem going ahead and marrying the sleezeball.

Expand full comment
Joey J's avatar

I'd love to see a movie about Josephine Baker. Just for the style/costumes/dress alone!

Expand full comment
MProvenza's avatar

HBO did a decent biopic in the early 90s I think.

Expand full comment
Maggie's avatar

Me too. She was a cabaret singer and spent WWII spying on the goddamn Nazi for the resistance. The fact that no one has made a movie about her boggles the mind.

Expand full comment
Alan Johnston's avatar

"The fact that no one has made a movie about her boggles the mind."

If anyone makes a movie about her, I hope it's the French. They just gave her a hero's burial in the Pantheon in Paris. Americans hardly know who she is -- and she was American, for heaven's sake. (As if helping defeat the Nazis wasn't enough, if memory serves correctly, she also adopted and raised 10 or 12 orphaned kids while she was at it.)

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Jul 26, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Maggie's avatar

I actually thought of you while reading an interview with the Greta Gerwig.

She was asked to cut a pivotal emotional scene from the movie because it didn't "move the plot forward" and she pointed out that if she removed the scene from the movie, then the movie wasn't "about anything" anymore. I can't imagine having conversations that maddening.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Jul 26, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment
TomD's avatar

Excellent!

Expand full comment