398 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
Craig Butcher's avatar

It is encouraging that there are in fact pro-lifers like Mona and Charlie (and a handful of others of my own acquaintance) who are truly pro-life, meaning pro-human.

It is discouraging that all of them together in America, assembled at a basketball game, would hardly be audible against the din of hatred and cruelty emitted by the anti-human "pro" lifers.

Expand full comment
Paul G's avatar

DonтАЩt get me wrong: IтАЩm not particularly impressed with the Monas and Charlies. They aligned themselves with genuinely awful people by convincing themselves that a greater good was at stake, but never bothered to convince (or even try very hard to convince) the public of the rightness of their position. They wanted to deny people what they had: Choice.

Even now, they have curled up in a ball and not confronted the Dan Patricks of the world.тАФCharlieтАЩs contention that the Texas case raises legitimate questions completely ducks the real issue. CharenтАЩs column of a couple of months ago in which she urged pro-lifers to support day care was clueless and had zero credibility.

Nonetheless, itтАЩs useful to get a detailed picture of the terrain,and some good might come of getting the Mona/Charlie faction to speak. At the very least, IтАЩd like to know where they actually stand on this horror show in Texas.

Expand full comment
Craig Butcher's avatar

I believe this week Texas came up and the consensus was that Ken Paxton personally is pretty much in the top rank of deplorables. as ever trod the stage of American politics.

If as a pro-life sympathizer, you have spent your formative years convincing yourself that the cause you are championing is entirely about protecting the innocent, and that abortion except in very very rare instances is actually just selfish people wantonly terminating pregnancies they have been too lazy to prevent through self control -- especially since championing that cause has been essential to your career success -- well, that's a pretty deep epistemological hole to climb out of.

Blind spots are everywhere.

Expand full comment
ErrorError