Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Carol S.'s avatar

Reposting some comments I just put on a JVL thread:

Trumpy intellectuals say they want to trim back the "administrative state" in order to restore democratic accountability -- which is fine as far is it goes. The promoters of Schedule F will say it's about letting a "duly elected president" enact his own agenda as the Constitution allows.

But when Donald Trump is the hero of that project -- and when Trump loyalists applaud playing hardball to prevent a Democratic president from enacting his agenda -- one has to suspect that something other than democratic accountability is at its heart. It looks more like: "A president who will do what I want should not be limited in any way -- or held accountable for illegal acts."

Trump himself clearly has an expansive view of presidential powers & immunities, and obviously believes that federal employees owe personal allegiance to him. His elite defenders aren't bothered by it. Instead, they've attacked those who insist that the president is not supposed to be a monarch.

Among hard-core Trumpites are people who suggest that democracy itself is problematic in that it allows the wrong kinds of people to gain power. And unlike much of America, they don't identify Trump as the wrong kind of person. Also in MAGA-land one can find a belief that the Constitution is defective insofar as it's informed by Enlightenment liberalism and doesn't give religion a dominant place in public life, and it allows cultural changes they dislike.

So if you delve into the world of those saying “We must restore and defend the American constitutional order," you may come upon a fantasy of repealing essential features of the Constitution and putting in place a different kind of governance.

Eva Seifert's avatar

Anyone who doesn't think that returning Trump to power and electing his Pets - that is every single 2020 election denier and Trump's enablers - is the equivalent of 1930s Germany is deliberately blind. I'm waiting for the black and brown uniforms to be handed out to each and every single Trump Pet. Bannon in his Tucker interview has already laid out what will happen if the Rs take Congress in a few months. Those Rs who will still vote for Trump despite decrying everything that's happened and Ds who are sticking their heads in the sand because of whatever will be just as complicit in Trump's crimes. They might remember that the war crimes trials after WW2 were actually harsher on people like them than on the higher ups.

200 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?