354 Comments

So get off your ass and join the campaign, Kelly. Bring Mattis and the others with you.

Expand full comment

The great barrier with Kelly being effective is that the electorate can't tell the difference between the character of a John Kelly and, say, the character of Sarah Huckabee Sanders.

Expand full comment

I think a simpler explanation is the electorate doesn't care about character. If it did, Trump wouldn't have been elected in 2016.

Expand full comment

What would Trump supporters do with the cognitive dissonance produced when the leader of a flag waving political movement is revealed to have called our war dead "losers" and "suckers?" They will simply refuse to believe it, and the mental gymnastics will involve believing that John Kelly is somehow corrupt.

Expand full comment

Yes, everyone is corrupt *except* Trump, who has been chosen by The Divine to "save" America. I wouldn't trust these people to operate a crayon, let alone vote.

Expand full comment

That made me spit out my coffee! You nailed it!

Expand full comment
Nov 21, 2023·edited Nov 22, 2023

I don't think they feel the cognitive dissonance. To them war produces guys with a chest full of medals. But thinking about the dead, the maimed, and those whose PTSD is very obvious makes them feel all icky inside, so they avoid thinking about that part entirely. Sort of like WW II movies...heroes. The only one that dealt with the aftermath in any accurate way was The Best Years of Our Lives in 1946. They skip over the Vietnam War movies as too icky.

Expand full comment

You got that right.

Expand full comment

MAGAs will always find a way to justify it, while the finest Trumpite thinkers say "Pay no attention to what he says! .... judges! .... woke tyranny! .... the Democrats are Marxists! .... This is our last chance to save America from the left!"

Expand full comment

I once got into a discussion about the stolen election and was told that "2000 Mules" proved that it was stolen. As part of my response, I noted that even Bill Barr thought it was "unimpressive". That's when I found out that Barr is a member of the Deep State. If it can happen to Bill Barr, it can certainly happen to John Kelly.

Expand full comment

My retired military officer family members love him. They hate their former congresswoman, Liz Cheney.

Expand full comment

That is so weird. My formerly Navy son regards TFG as a traitor to the oath to the Constitution which he also swore to, and still feels bound by.

Expand full comment

Cognitive dissonance…

Expand full comment

Many don’t know or don’t believe the true reports of his character defects. They’ve been conditioned to believe the attacks and reports are exaggerations and lies.

Expand full comment

That doesn't mean they're off the hook, Stephen. We have 50+ years of documentation that shows Trump is a wretched piece of filth. If these people are ignorant to those facts, that's because they're choosing to be so. My own theory is they support Trump just to piss people off and they don't care about the danger that he poses to our national and global security.

Expand full comment

In my opinion, you're underestimating how effective Trump and his media allies have been at discrediting what they call the mainstream media. If its in the New York Times, its false.

Expand full comment

Oh, I don't underestimate it at all, Lewis. I simply people that these people want to be lied to because that way, they're not responsible for their choices. Keep in mind that Trump's more egregious public moments -- like calling for Mark Milley's execution, or the termination of the Constitution -- happened on Truth Social and is part of the public record. Has he lost any support for those comments amongst the base?

Expand full comment
founding

Also,"you gonna believe your lying eyes or me". Trump 2020

Expand full comment

Trumpler and media allies think American people are stupid - information-challenged, prone to conspiracy theories, easily manipulated, having cultish behavior.

Hmm, what to do about it as reach the edge of cliff, after watching our democracy slip away one day at a time for 8+ years...?

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

And, I think that because all they know/have experienced is America as a democracy/republic/whatever, because it appears to be stable, they think it is a feature of nature and can not change. And even if tRump gets back in, with all the attendant slime and freaks, that everything will just keep merrily going along.

Expand full comment

Even of Trump gets the US to fight along side Russia to capture all of Eastern Europe.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Sometimes I feel like we're living in an episode of The Twilight Zone.

Expand full comment

I am stealing "their complete loserness" from you.

Just so you know=:-)

Expand full comment

Omg, truth is so hard to bear.

Going over a cliff in a slow motion...😱

Expand full comment

People who are conditioned to follow faith instead of facts, are dangerous to any democracy. That’s why the wolves are so suddenly fond of Christianity as a weapon.

Expand full comment
founding

One word ;cult.

Expand full comment
founding

Once again, right on GG.

Expand full comment

Evidenced by unending trouble in Middle East.

Religion, religious extremism, amplifies ignorance, controls & divides people, causes wars…

Expand full comment

I have felt for a long time that the more fundamentally religious you are, the less you are on the side of democracy. For democracy requires compromise, a willingness to listen to other views, and admitting that you don’t have all the answers. None of those things describe people who are steeped in fundamentalist religions. Their views boil down to these two things: (1) they believe they know what the rules are, and (2) they don’t believe they are allowed to change the rules.

Expand full comment

My brother has stopped talking to me since he became a fundamentalist. Not at first. He tried for years to get me and my husband and kids on board his totally fundamentalist train. Finally gave up and won't speak to us anymore. His wife occasionally calls from a pay phone.

Expand full comment

One thing I wonder; why is religiosity causing so much division now, here? Especially as we have become more secular as a nation, according to polling data. I can only assume it’s something about Trumpism which is so counterintuitive considering what an ungodly specimen he is, not even attempting to mask his hateful thoughts. It must be a fluke convergence of forces I don’t understand.

Expand full comment

MAGAs have always said that critics are swallowing "media narratives" about Trump -- even when people can play the videos that show him displaying his wretched character all by himself,

Trump voters are obviously not much offended by the manifest awfulness. Trump fans clearly love the awfulness.

Expand full comment

Amplifying and harnessing grievance, resentment, anger, hate. Just like Hitler…

Expand full comment

There's no better example of this than Trump's Evangelical supporters. It was only a few years ago that the "moral character" of the President was paramount. Lack of "moral character" was almost an impeachable offense. Now, they view "moral character" as so 1998.

Expand full comment

If Kelly had character, he wouldn’t have taken the chief-of-staff job. He and we all knew very well at that point what the Orange Pustule was all about.

Expand full comment

Right? Kelly et al just sound bitter and whiny. Now that they've been kicked off the gravy train, they want to "tell all" that happened on said train. The "half day bounce" was the shelf life of his book.

Expand full comment

They love it because they are narrow minded suckers that hope he will hurt the people they hate. They don't really care about the troops, only that if they fight, they must win, to make us feel like winners. The wounded and dead ARE losers because they aren't Rambo or GIJoe.

Expand full comment

To be fair, I don't think there is a lot of daylight in the character of those two. Both are just appalling.

Expand full comment
Nov 21, 2023·edited Nov 21, 2023

Exactly. All the Republican insiders who have privately (or not so privately) trashed Trump must come out publicly and in some coordinated fashion to say loud and clear: 1) how bad he is and the threat that he poses and 2) state that everyone who loves their country and reveres the Constitution should vote for any non-Trumpy Republican in the primary and for Biden if in fact the choice in the general is Trump v Biden.

That we are in an emergency situation, desperate times etc.

Elaborate that preserving our stability, prosperity, and peace as a nation in the short-term requires this, after which rebuilding the Republican party and working to identify a non-fascist candidate who respects the Constitution to compete in 2028 can commence.

This will not move most of the base, but will give the Republican voters who don't like Trump but despise Dems enough doubts along with the permission structure to at least stay home. It could very well make the difference.

Expand full comment

Yes it's time for him to get out there and spill the beans, all of them. I am sure he has been witness to much more depravity, treason and illegality than he's said so far. That would truly fulfill his oath to serve his country.

Expand full comment

That's coming in his follow up memoir

You aren't suggesting he spills the beans for free are you? /s lol

Expand full comment

Charlie, regarding Auggie. One of the truest lines I ever read, “The crulest trick God ever played on man is making dogs’ lives so short.”

Expand full comment

My pinned tweet:

"Every time a dog I love dies, they take a piece of my heart with them. And every time a new dog comes into my life, they give me a piece of their heart. If I live long enough, all the pieces of my heart will be dog, and I will become as generous and loving as they are."

Expand full comment

We should all aspire to be the kind of person our dogs think we are.

Expand full comment
founding

I wonder what dogs think of Trump?

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
founding

Remember the reaction of that bald eagle (a few years ago) when Trump was holding him.Priceless.

Expand full comment

Or at least back away and growl.

Expand full comment

I totally trust my dogs' intuition about people. They instinctively know evil.

Expand full comment

I totally trust my dog. If, on a walk, he spots a person or people in the distance and refuses to move forward, we turn around and go the other way.

Expand full comment

Dogs know.

Expand full comment

We don't deserve dogs but im glad they think we do.

Expand full comment
founding

Sko, thank you for your lovely words. We cat people feel devastated, too, when our feline family members have to leave us. Pieces of my heart will be cat.

Expand full comment

Nancy, mine too

Expand full comment

Thank you for this…

Expand full comment

I've never heard that before, it's lovely.

Expand full comment

One of those gems you find on the internet, by an unknown author.

Expand full comment

I love it (probably not surprising given my avatar :-P). However, I'm afraid if I try to say it to anyone, I'll cry right then and there!

Expand full comment
founding

well put

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

I found it one day years ago on one of those sites with tons of quotes about dogs.

Another favorite: "A door is something a dog is always on the wrong side of." :)

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

I have that sign in my kitchen, but instead of the dog, there's a pig!

(I worked with pigs over 30 years, so everyone in my family gave me everything with a pig on it for literal decades until I begged them to stop!)

Expand full comment

Cats, too. Though I am honored I got to spend years with many wonderful cats & dogs (& hamsters & guinea pigs). My cats are approaching 15 and I appreciate them every day except when Christian wakes me up at 5am.

Expand full comment
founding

I can add dutch bunnies to that collection.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

One day, 2 guys from the AC company arrived to install my new ACs in NYC. Christian sat in front of me with his tail wrapped all the way around my ankles. I knew one of them was bad news. He’s never done that before or since.

Expand full comment

I lost my (most recent) dog in February of this year. She was 15. I still wake up every morning thinking about her.

The short lifespans of our best friends are indeed the curse of dog lovers. They're with us long enough that we learn to love them like children, then they're gone.

Expand full comment

I know, right? They break your heart in the end.

Expand full comment
founding

Kind of like life.

Expand full comment

I know, right? My dog's been gone for 30 years and I still miss her.

Expand full comment

They do, but they also leave you stronger and more open to love.

Expand full comment

Oh, I know. I still miss my dog after 30 years. I miss one of my best friend's dog, and one of my sister-in-law's dog. It's just tough to say goodbye.

Expand full comment

I still miss my Rottie. He was the most compassionate being I have ever known with gentle brown eyes so full of love.

Expand full comment

Mine was a retriever/lab mix, and she was absolutely bonkers in the best way. Just crazy, with a jealous streak to match. But she was also exceptional around children and quite protective of them. We don't deserve dogs, NLTownie.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

True, true!

Expand full comment
founding

Great quote!

Expand full comment

Checkov wrote an excellent short story about that.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Thank you!! I can't find the story now; it was in a high school Norton Anthology. The man was amazing; a physician and such a prolific author!

Expand full comment

I have sometimes thought of the final cause of dogs having such short lives and I am quite satisfied it is in compassion to the human race; for if we suffer so much in losing a dog after an acquaintance of ten or twelve years, what would it be if they were to live double that time? The misery of keeping a dog is his dying so soon. But, to be sure, if he lived for fifty years and then died, what would become of me?” – Sir Walter Scott

Expand full comment
founding

They become family.

Expand full comment

So very true 😥

Expand full comment

Those folks who built up Candace Owens should’ve read the book instead of just watching the movies. In the book, Dr. Frankenstein ends up in the frozen north trying to track down his creation to kill it. Good luck to them with all the monsters they’ve made.

Expand full comment

The strange part is that they started their critique of her with her "Israel is an apartheid state" position, which was discussed in Foreign Policy magazine earlier this year. The article came down on the side of Israel having all the attributes of an apartheid state. Foreign Policy isn't known for craziness.

Expand full comment

I was going to make a similar point.

Expand full comment
founding

"If only they were warned". " Leopards eating faces" party

Expand full comment
founding

"Beware of riding the tiger, lest you be eaten by him"

Expand full comment

“I came out and told people the awful things he said about wounded soldiers, and it didn’t have half a day’s bounce. You had his attorney general Bill Barr come out, and not a half a day’s bounce."

With all due respect, general, you came out and told people those thing IN A BOOK, YEARS AFTER THE FACT. You were in a better position to observe Trump's behavior and warn the nation than just about any other person on the planet. And you remained silent. When the chips were down, you stayed silent until you could make a buck on a book deal. Your words now aren't totally worthless, but they're a hell of a lot less valuable now than they could have been.

Expand full comment

So much this. "The Warning", "The Room Where It Happened" - whatever. No one will take you seriously because the orange one is too far entrenched now. Now it just sounds like courage born of too much alcohol. They were full of hubris, they thought they could handle him, keep their powerful positions and their party.

Those guys should've shouted Wolf! when it mattered.

Expand full comment
founding

"Beware of riding the tiger, lest you be eaten by him"

Expand full comment

Wow. I hope someone close to him says this to him. Maybe then he will actually do more.

Expand full comment

I think, “with all do respect” is more than he deserves, but I understand the impulse.

I have 2 nephews currently serving, one would probably speak up and one wouldn’t. It is a challenge to understand. :(

Expand full comment

Charlie, the Fortune 500 executives are too busy criticizing the junior year liberal arts major at Columbia protesting the Israel-Hamas war to criticize the richest man on the planet! If only all of the people that are worried about speech on campus had the same amount of attention for a large recipient of American tax dollars pushing baseless anti-Semitic conspiracy theories. I’m glad we all kept things in perspective over the last month.

Expand full comment

“It’s beyond my comprehension he has the support he has.”…

Here' an answer from this podunk, hicksville Trumptown I live in. With snowmobiles, four-wheelers, jacked up pickups, and fifty inch flat panels in households galore, it is not about the economy. It is not about planet threatening futures of their children. It's about grievance. Essentially, it's about their soul soothing sheer loathing of all but themselves. It's collective narcissism, founded on sheer

Hate.

Expand full comment

I have a theory that many believe there is something besides the government that helps them - “keep the government out of my Medicare” - so it kinda doesn’t matter if the candidates they elect want to burn it all down. The mysterious “they” will make sure FEMA checks go out, their Social Security cost of living updates are implemented correctly, passport requests get processed, etc. Because they don’t understand how the government really works, they think it’s great for Trump to destroy the deep state without the slightest idea what that would mean.

We have clean air and water because companies want to treat factory waste out of the goodness of their hearts, right? Food labels say what’s actually inside the package because companies are super honest, aren’t they? It couldn’t be government regulations forcing them, could it?

Expand full comment

I agree with this ^. Situational ignorance. Not to make excuses, but understanding how the world works is sometimes beyond the intellectual capacity of a portion of the electorate. That's why parts of the electorate are so easily manipulated. I never take for granted my own intelligence, drive and curiosity with a --but for the grace of God, there go I--mantra.

Expand full comment

It's their turn to be oppressed, be a victim.

*eyeroll*

Expand full comment

You are 100% right. No one but them and people like them have the right to live and breath.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Some of them. Some learned stuff and are well off and still hate everyone not like them.

Expand full comment

........this column has me almost as depressed as a JVL column..........=:-o

Expand full comment

My goodness, Charlie, you have a beautiful dog. I hope Auggie has a long, healthy, happy life.

As for the news, I'm so tired of adults acting like 5 year olds. From the article on Owens you quoted: "For example, she has falsely compared Israel to the “segregated South.” This is the sort of ignorant ‘Apartheid State” slander that we expect from Black Lives Matter – and the Jew-killers of the Middle East."

For the love of God, people, why the drive-by shooting to Black Lives Matter? We know the only thing they "expect" is that they can keep using the phrase to scare White bigots because it has the word Black in it. I'm so tired of being treated like a thug because I'm not a bigot. So tired of hearing that Trump is going to end democracy but he's going to win because Biden is old and nobody cares about democracy. It's wrong and I'm tired of the propaganda today.

Thank you, Charlie, for noticing that when students hang their bare asses out, the news media gleefully reports it for weeks, but when Musk, a billionaire, hangs his bare ass out the same exact way, he gets praise and imitators. Funny how that happens.

Expand full comment

If the big money people didn't dump all over college kids the next thing you know those kids might be agitating to unionize Starbucks or Tesla.

Expand full comment
founding

Unionizing Tesla.What would Elon think of that? Probably a lawsuit.

Expand full comment

Bingo

Expand full comment

I should hope charlie noticed considering he's guilty of the spending weeks dumping on college students charge.

Expand full comment

Isn’t it odd that a mainstream publication like Foreign Policy even concluded that Israel shares many traits of an apartheid state? Truth is an absolute defense against slander and it’s disappointing that Charlie gave credence to such a line.

Expand full comment
Nov 21, 2023·edited Nov 21, 2023

General Kelly: "If anything, his numbers go up."

That's because roughly 30% of the electorate are shit-tier human beings. They are comfortable with Trump being awful because they themselves are awful. And they should be treated accordingly.

I'm glad to hear Auggie's on the mend. He's a good boy.

Expand full comment

Perhaps citizens would take better notice if Kelly & Barr say they would vote for a democtat instead of Trump, this is the line they don't want to cross. But Trump love will not decline unless GOPers say Biden is not the evil we portray him to be.

Expand full comment

Oh, I totally agree. I think Barr is particularly shameful on this. He has acknowledged in many interviews on Trump's unfitness for office yet will support Trump against Joe Biden. For once, I'd like one of these interviewers to say, "Mr. Barr, while I respect your government service, you are completely and utterly full of shit and by not supporting Joe Biden for president, you are complicit in the destruction of our country. So, fuck right off with that."

Of course, that'll never happen.

Expand full comment

I just read Jeff Tiedrich's free substack newsletter and this is today's topic - he always cuts through the BS.

I don't care if they give 10 caveats about how Democrats spend too much and are too in-your-face about accepting "weird" LGBTQ stuff, they need to end with their own truth. "I never imaged voting for a Democrat for President, but democracy requires it if the other choice is Trump."

Expand full comment

And we have always, since the revolution until now, that 30%. Every now and then they get permission to show their true selves. TFG has amplified them and co-opted others that just want power. This is our showdown. And it will probably last for more than one more election cycle. They are not going to go quietly into the night.

We sure better have our big boy pants on, every single one of us.

Expand full comment
founding

“Shit-tier human beings” —that hits the nail squarely on the head.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Hillary understated it, if anything.

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Hillary would have been a truly great President. I am sad to say, I think it will be a very long time before the United States has a woman for President. To many, being a woman is even more of a disqualifier than being Black.

Expand full comment

David Horowitz Freedom Center on Candace Owens: "Her comments about Israel and her promotion of people like Andrew Tate are part of a pattern."

Oh? People like Andrew Tate? Can you think of anyone else as odious as Andrew Tate that she might have been eager to promote six years ago? Something that might have served as a clue to her character? Here's a hint: she wasn't the only one! Here's another hint. This is from the ... *checks notes* ... David Horowitz Freedom Center:

"Candace Owens has become obsessed with her own fame, stirring up drama to compensate for a lack of real achievement."

Remind you of anyone? Come on, you're close, I can feel it! Here's another, same source:

"Candace tackles a subject she knows nothing about, never bothers to learn anything about it, and then rides the backlash by playing the victim to generate more fame and money."

C'mon, I've practically told you their name at this point. What's that? You know a lot of people like that? Oh. Right. Of course.

Never mind.

Expand full comment

Are people like that born, or made? Not an original question but it comes to mind almost everyday, because I marvel at the manipulative skills these people possess. I lack both the desire and the necessary skills to control other people, so it fascinates me. Why? How?

Expand full comment

Normally made. Someone I once knew very well (or so I thought) turned out to be a pathological liar. It appears to have been nurtured as a survival skill from a youth of shitty parenting. This clearly applies to Trump.

Expand full comment

I read Mary Trump’s book about her uncle. It did seem like a cold, aloof family. I’m often fascinated by people who emerge from those unfortunate upbringings with a reasonably healthy personality. That clearly doesn’t apply to Trump.

I guess I’m surprised how widespread the evil power of manipulation is practiced with skill; all the Trump sycophants have it, it’s not just him. Scott Atlas, the radiologist who commandeered the Covid strategy is but one example. There’s another irritating figure whose name I can’t recall; lied all the time with great aggression. So many!

Expand full comment
Nov 21, 2023·edited Nov 21, 2023

So, there's actually a few different types here. The pathological liars have to be smart enough to keep their stories straight. Trump isn't, so he's a pathological bullshitter, which makes him trickier to deal with.

The bullshitters are the carnival barkers. They make great talk radio hosts as long as they have a good call screener. These people are usually having one-way conversations with friendly crowds, and limit their one-on-one dialogs to sympathetic ears. They say whatever they want because they can expect not to be called out on it. Once in a while Trump gets the itch to prove himself in front of real journalists (without an audience) and it never goes well. He can't handle the confrontation and generally looks like a fool.

People like Atlas are different. They're the contrarians. The people so convinced they're right when everyone else in their knowledge field disagrees with them – in fact, even moreso *because* everyone disagrees with them. They have a chip on their shoulder and think they're the Albert Einstein of their field – because they think other physicists thought Einstein was crazy (they didn't). They believe what they're saying, though.

As far as the manipulation goes, I hate to say this, but I think most of us would probably be better at it than we'd like to believe, if we really felt we needed to. Just think about all of the thoughts and impulses we suppress, the little white lies we tell in order to maintain a general aura of civility. And it all requires people skills: the ability to read a room, to understand what motivates people, what triggers them, what they respond well to, etc. Which is fine.

But if you abandon honestly as a general virtue, you lose a sense of guilt and shame about being deceptive, and you can use those skills for outright manipulation. That's why people say Trump's superpower is his shamelessness – that's the difference between persuading and manipulating. Any politician could do what he does if they lacked a conscience. Most of us could, I imagine.

Expand full comment

It helps if you view yourself as smart and everyone else as a sucker. Because if you are willing to lie, cheat and steal to get what you want, you can always find people who will believe you. Just like some of the right wing nut cases who make money telling gullible people it's okay to be racist and anti feminist and ant gay. There are folks eager for someone to give them permission to hate and they will swallow any lie and will also give the huckster their hard earned money.

Expand full comment
founding

Nature or Nurture? In Trump s case?

Expand full comment

Glib answer: In Trump's case, Nature and Nurture.

Expand full comment
founding

In Trump’s case I’d say nature and nurture have been inextricably fused in the matter transporter from the Fly.

Expand full comment

Long live David Cronenberg!

Expand full comment
founding

TRUMP.Do I win something now?

Expand full comment

How about the clarity of mind to know what's happening and how little you can do to stop it as you watch your country fall apart of its own accord?

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Oh, I think I maybe heard of this guy! He should understand Owens then; as I understand she basically took the same route to her crazy. Classic extremophiles. A sensible person who becomes disenchanted with the extremities of their political persuasion becomes some kind of moderate. The people with the worst judgement do a 180° flip.

Expand full comment

I heard of Ramparts thanks to Mort Sahl’s show in LA, but never got it. Did you read Harlan Ellison’s column in the Freep? He was great.

Expand full comment
RemovedNov 21, 2023·edited Nov 21, 2023
Comment removed
Expand full comment

Wow. Yeah, I have gathered he went a bit off the rails there. It reminds me of how much I admired Elizabeth Kübler-Ross, and was totally off put when she seemed to go “a bit do-lally”, as the British say, at the last there. Or Elon, who impressed me so much I invested $1,000 in Tesla on Day One of IPO, before getting out 3 years later when he seemed to go sideways too. It’s sad to see people you respected behave in such a way as to lose that respect.

Expand full comment

Interesting. I read a lot of Ellison back in the 80's.

Expand full comment

John Kelly knows from his military experience how to launch a sustained campaign.

He should try it with Trump.

Expand full comment

Kelly was an anon source for a book after trump left office; he didn't really "speak out" until recently --- and then expects people to someone listen to his opinion and change there own??? All these people coming out of the word work to speak is just really appalling.

Kelly and the other generals need to cut a testimonial ad to support Biden. I doubt they will though, that would take some stones.

On another note --- I was a student at Kansas when they were filming The Day After and was actually in a couple of scenes in the background. It was an interesting few weeks. They just put out to students and people in the community to show up in various places around town to be in the movie.

Expand full comment

I was not in the film (that must have been fun! and also boring, from what I know of being an extra). But I did see it with my friends, broadcast in one of our college eateries. It was grim.

Expand full comment

An online friend mentioned that he was supposed to be an extra on the film one day, but had to work in the Science Library at Malott Hall.

The twitter profile of Malott Hall is hilarious: I'm a movie star and fallout shelter, and you're not.

Expand full comment

I knew someone who was in the grocery store grabbing all the meat out of the counter she was there most of the day for only about seconds on the screen.

My car at the time (1970 Duster) would have been in scene of all the cars leaving town but I also had a test on the same day

Expand full comment

They need to do more than cut an ad. They need to go on a campaign trail type of tour, each and every one of them. Let local news report it and write it up. A grassroots type of thing. Do they really want tRump to go down, or are they simply hoping and praying?

Expand full comment

They are really looking to re-write the history of their own complicity.

Expand full comment

I was looking for a common thread between Mike Lee, Elon Musk, Donald Trump, Candace Owens, and the downfall of common cultural touchstones like "The Day After", and I think they link up in the tendency of Americans to retreat into their own bespoke, curated alternate realities.

One of the things the Internet has made possible is that if you never want to engage with someone who disagrees with your worldview, no matter how bizarre it may be, you can find people online who agree, or at least pretend to agree to make money. The fact that the "Pizzagate" alternative reality is now sufficiently accepted that powerful state politicians are appearing on radio shows that cater to a conspiracy theory that is frankly not far from paranoid schizophrenia is one sign. Mike Lee refusing to abandon his belief that the January 6th insurrection was an inside job to smear MAGA is another. When the facts don't fit his theory, he just grabs another set of facts.

People like to blame Fox News for poisoning minds, but Fox News is serving a market of Americans who want to be told that they're right and upstanding, and the rest of the country is evil and scary. If Fox came to their senses, OANN, Newsmax, and the Internet are there to provide the same service. I think that Fox viewers would simply switch over to a new provider. People are starting to secede from reality to live in their own fantasy worlds, and it scares the hell out of me.

Expand full comment

Like Voltaire said, “Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.” We should all be very scared.

Expand full comment

I am.

Expand full comment
founding

Trump for example

Expand full comment
Comment removed
Expand full comment

I knew the words of the quote but not the origin so I Googled it and Voltaire popped up first. He must be on the take, to be the first hit!

Expand full comment
Nov 21, 2023·edited Nov 21, 2023

I'm having trouble with the information siloes theory these days. Did everyone really have universal info back in the day when there were only 3 channels on TV? I doubt it. But they could live in blissful ignorance of everyone else's opinions on most issues day to day except for a few key ones. Now they know drag queens, atheists, and students not fully in unconditional love with the nation state of Israel exist and have opinions and they *HATE* it.

I think this is the storm before opinion and culture are relatively homogenized out to the reach of the internet and social media as opposed to just the reach of TV and radio.

Expand full comment
Nov 21, 2023·edited Nov 21, 2023

The silos these days don’t sit in lonely isolation; they’re networked. The Internet connected many pre-existing silos, and among other things, that taught extremists that they have each other in far greater numbers than they ever imagined. Back in the day they had to make do with typewritten mailing lists, journals that got mailed out 12 or 26 times a year, syndicated radio talk shows in the wee hours, letters to the editor that made it past the gatekeepers, and xeroxes pinned to supermarket bulletin boards. The Internet dramatically strengthened connections among these silos, and Republican funders and politicians soon grokked their potential. Now extremists and conspiracy theorists are very well-funded and tightly integrated with the right-wing arms of state and federal politics and the mainstream media. Their takes filter out to all our silos, whether we’re believers, debunkers, or just spectators.

Expand full comment

They had more people who read newspapers,(100s of newspapers,) and weekly news magazines that had a tradition of reporting opposing views. The Fairness Doctrine made it a point to give both side of an issue a platform. That was done away with for express purpose of blanketing the country with propaganda.

Expand full comment

Thank you for sharing about your dog. I totally relate. Dogs are the most wonderful companions and yet their life spans are so short, so we live through their whole life with the joy, and then the loss. I love my dog so much. All of us dog lovers understand.

Expand full comment

So happy for the Sykes family and Auggie!

Cat lovers are no less sentimental and bonded beyond reason to these furry masters.

Expand full comment

I've had my heart broken by both, but as I've matured--gotten old--I've had cats. My daughter the dog lover, calls me daily to find out what my 'owners' have put the slave through today.

Expand full comment

John Kelly has long been a mystery to me. His military career was stellar. His dedication to the United States cannot possibly be questioned. He's made sacrifices none of us should have to make.

He was interviewed back in 2019 on the Naval Institute Proceedings Podcast. It's very much worth the listen:

https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/the-proceedings-podcast/episode-108-gen-john-kelly-looks-back

His work in Latin America on combatting the drug trade is particularly interesting in light of his service in the Trump Administration. John Kelly knows the truth about what's going on in Central and South America. He knows the sacrifices the militaries and police forces in those countries are dealing with, the risks they taken when they burn a field or mess with the cartels. He understands these things on a level most of us don't. Yet he stood by as Trump did what he did, ignorant of even the most basic facts.

I'm sure he was in the "if not me, then the next guy will be worse" camp and he was probably right about that. He's also, at his heart a US Marine, which means something, including when the President of the United States asks you to do something, you do it.

But now ... how? I don't know what the right answer is, but it seems to me John Kelly's got one more mission to complete and it's waking the MAGA horde up to the truth of what Donald Trump really is.

Expand full comment

I suspect a lot of Cassandras told John Kelly not to take the job because Trump is a sucking black hole of character, but he didn't listen to them. And now he's a Cassandra himself. He could talk to the people who warned him and figure out where he went wrong, but I'll place a $100 bet he's not going to do that. Better to let the country detonate than admit liberals were correct about one thing.

Expand full comment

It’s galling. Patriotism only goes so far. But you’d think someone who sacrificed a son to the country would feel standing up to Trump to be insignificant by comparison. And yet.

Expand full comment
founding

Its galling that anyone thinks that those who sacrificed their lives in every war are "saps and suckers".

Expand full comment

That alone should have given Kelley the spine he needed to speak out. His “honor” is mysteriously MIA.

Expand full comment
founding

"I was silent.Then they came for me" This quote is very shortened.I don't remember who said it.But it is chilling(regarding WW2) It kind of sums up today, doesn't it!

Expand full comment

It does sum up today’s political environment. The people who know that quote aren’t the ones who need to know it, as usual. If Trump gets voted in again, there will be some very unhappy Trump voters once the sh*t hits the fan and they get fouled along with everyone else. Sarah’s recent Focus Group with Bill Kristol and a gaggle of Jewish Trump voters comes to mind, as but one small example among a big pool of stooges.

Expand full comment
Nov 21, 2023·edited Nov 21, 2023

I have trouble understanding the Kelly reaction too. The best I can come up with is that deep down in most every senior military officer's DNA is a complete dedication to serving the chain of command even when you may not agree with it. Of course, there are many other factors regarding them being a bit insulated from the outside world (i.e. not really knowing what it looks like for the ordinary citizen), plenty of their own problems to do deal with (i.e. day-to-day stuff), not sure how you would address it successfully and finally...the specter of the shix-storm created by revealing the truth and how that would play out for him personally, professionally and for the country.

Not saying any of that's right...but that's my take on why Kelly, like Frank Sinatra, did it his way...

Expand full comment

For all the doom out there, it was nice to get an update on Auggie. Glad he’s on the mend.

Expand full comment

Love that handsome pup. And his gigantic baby brother. Thanks for sharing this happy news.

Expand full comment