Sam Stein and Tim Miller break down the grotesque and dangerous rhetoric from GOP Reps. Andy Ogles and Nancy Mace, who suggested deporting New York mayoral candidate and naturalized U.S. citizen Zohran Mamdani. We go beyond the outrage to explain how trolling rhetoric like this is often a precursor to actual policy, and why ignoring it is not an option.
As always: Watch, listen, and leave a comment. Bulwark+ Takes is home to short videos, livestreams, and event archives exclusively for Bulwark+ members.
Don’t care for video? Use the controls on the left side of the player to toggle to audio.
Add Bulwark+ Takes feed to your player of choice, here.
I'm a frequent critic of the way Sam conducts himself on podcasts (because of his habit of constantly interrupting other people) but I really liked Sam here: concise, articulate and passionate, Well done Sam!
Since you posted this video, a man from Florida has died in ICE detention
The family is devastated
T , Homan , Noem all of them charged and put on trial in International Court for human rights violations ???!!!
The Christian nationalists do not want the Muslims in our country. It’s all about religion.
Religion has started many wars in the history of civilization.
There is a reason why our founding fathers created this country in our constitution to have absolute separation of church and state.
Christian nationalism has corrupted our country
Barack Obama was right when he said it went back to the days of the Crusades
Sam, you mention here about a person being taken off the streets that was missed in media and how it is impossible to keep track of those disappearing .
Please consider this and read to the end.
I really think this should be pointed out by everybody over and over offering the true narrative as to why this brutality is going on. We are definitely in a crisis.
Facts :
They now are calling for Zohran Mamdani to be deported .
They are targeting anybody and everybody for removal while masked up showing no credentials .
They have started early gerrymandering again.
Please check out Marjorie Taylor Green’s latest pathological lying gaslighting deceptive tweet about pushing through an early census.
She tweets :
“I just got off the phone with President Trump!!
I told him about my new bill I am introducing that will save America's elections from ever being stolen again!”
They just passed this horrible Bill 51 to 50
Trump just tweeted :
“Trump calls for deporting US citizens: "We also have a lot of bad people that have been here for a long time ... many of them were born in our country. I think we ought to get them the hell out of here too, if you want to know the truth. So maybe that'll be the next job."
The Republicans have been very skilled practitioners of gaslighting and created the narrative for decades that the Democrats only want immigrants because they are the only ones “that vote for Democrats” ( see below Trump’s words at G7)
Then they continued extreme gaslighting, creating the narrative about the invasion at the border and danger and criminals and mentally ill invading us trying to create a crisis and an emergency.
Just like the manufacturer created emergency and crisis Trump created in Los Angeles to be able to send the National Guard in the military.
Also remember this gaslighting? It’ll show at the end.
https://youtu.be/xXd20VDrLII
THERE IS A METHOD TO THEIR MADNESS .
Dean Bloundel Canadian journalist first reported on the G7 meeting with a video clip of Trump which is available for all to see now.
The piece that stands out to me the most in that video clip of Trump, who at the same time was defending Russia and saying they should be at the G7 meeting Bloundel reported:
“Targeting U.S. “enemy” cities:
In the very same media scrum, Trump ABRUPTLY PIVOTED to DOMESTIC politics, bragging about a new push to deport immigrants from Democratic-run “sanctuary cities.” He railed that “most of those people are in…all blue cities, all Democrat-run cities, and they think they’re going to use them to VOTE. It’s not going to happen”.
Listen and read his words carefully he is speaking it out loud
“THEY’RE NOT GOING TO USE THEM TO VOTE”
Doing all of this to affect the upcoming midterm elections.
He was actually telling why they’re targeting blue states and cities trying to purge all immigrants because once again they’re trying to purge the voters control voting limit voting.
Plus Noem declared they were going to never go away and they’re going to “LIBERATE “California.
From their own duly ELECTED officials !!
Always trying to overturn an election and go against the will of the people.
They tried to do this on January 6 when they mounted the most violent attack and treasonous insurrection trying to take over our Capitol building to stop the certification of a legitimate election and go against the will of the people.
They even went so far as to create illegally a FAKE SET OF ELECTORS from several states and manipulated to try to get the fake set of electors read into the record rep replacing the real ones that day.
They have tried to undermine and destroy the Federal Voting Rights Act of 1965 at every turn and at every state level
Yes, indeed, Trump announced at the G7 why they were going after the immigrants in the democratic blue state and cities.
The fact that he is president of the United States and he talks about blue versus red states and still wears his red Maga hat instead of being president for the whole of the United States of America and all Americans is just outrageous, offensive and perverted.
Nothing is presidential with integrity and honor, defending the constitution of the United States of America and our democracy.
All of this has been pushed through normal channels, which is impossible when there is no equivalency for what’s going on.
They know they cannot win fairly and by their pure nature, they don’t want to.
The Republican Party is dead gutted out .
We need a healthy Republican Party in this country for democracy.
In a democracy that’s working there is bipartisan cooperation. Each side it’s supposed to be considered to having good ideas coming together to negotiate on behalf of the good of the American people defending our constitution and our democracy.
That is not what we have had in decades
McCarthyism from the 50s in Wisconsin never went away the Nixon people and the corruption never went away
Fascism authoritarianism that reared his head in the 30s and 40s never went away
after the purging of the John Birch society (so they thought ) - never went away
History is repeating itself from the 30s and 40s with Germany
Tim , Sam and Substack Bulwark friends
I read this a few days ago and hope all can read .
It really puts things into perspective especially about the word “socialist.”
Written by Kevin Dolgin who is affiliate professor at the Sorbonne Business School in Paris where he teaches entrepreneurship and consumer behavior in the MBA program. A graduate of Fordham University (USA), INSEAD and of the Sorbonne Business School. Born in New York City, has lived in Paris for 30 years.
He writes :
“It seems to me that this habit of viewing other developed nations as “socialist”, is a uniquely American trait, and one that is rather new.
I’m going to make a bold statement: THERE ARE NO SOCIALIST COUNTRIES, at least not in the developed world. Even China, which is nominally communist (therefore socialist) has greatly opened up its economy to private ownership since the death of Mao, and today, about 70% of the economy is in private hands (see What percentage of the Chinese economy is state-owned?). There remain parties that have “socialist” in their names, but even they are not actually militating for a socialist system.
Socialism is a specific economic / political form of society in which the means of production are owned by the population as a whole, typically through the government. The Soviet Union and its satellites were socialist.
There is no developed country in which the means of production are all owned by the government. There are many countries in which certain companies are owned by the government, typically companies dealing with public goods, such as railroads, utilities, etc. In France, the national rail service is owned by the government, for example, and in the United States, the postal service is government owned. This does not make either of the two countries socialist.
Neither is there any developed nation that is truly entirely “capitalist”, if capitalism means allowing only Adam Smith’s invisible hand to regulate business. In the 19th century, for example, capitalism in most countries was given a freer hand. However, in the late part of the century and early part of the 20th century, just about every country started regulating it more closely. For example, in the United States in 1900 there were no child labor laws, no laws against workplace discrimination, no laws limited the workweek, no right to strike, no anti-trust laws… etc. Likewise, there was virtually no public “safety nets”, i.e. transfer payments to the poor, disabled, orphans, etc. This was similar to other nations.
Since then, most countries have instituted all of these laws, regulations and public aid programs. Some have gone farther than others. In France total governmental spending as a percent of GDP is quite high, at 56.7%, as compared to 37.6% in the United States. This could be seen as a general idea of the role of government in the economy, so the country has clearly decided to move more to the “left” of the United States economically, as have most nations.
Most Americans I meet and talk to are rather international and it has become clear to me that opinions back in the States are very different.
It strikes me that there is an American (or at least alt-right) obsession with calling everything that isn’t strictly conservative “socialist”. Those who do this seem to get quite agitated about it as well, becoming angry with said “socialists”. I was flummoxed to see that these same people sometimes even go so far as to state that the Nazis were socialists too, and that Nazism was a leftist ideology: apparently because the word “socialist” is part of the party’s name, which would indicate that North Korea is democratic… but that’s another story.
I have the impression that there’s a certain nostalgia for the cold war, when there were good Americans and evil commies. Now that the commies are gone, “socialists” have become the new bogeymen, whether they are lurking in the Assemblée Nationale or in the Democratic party. But those same people were fighting the cold war too, and we all won! Hurray! No one wants Soviet-style socialism, or any other socialism. The French, as well as other citizens of developed countries all want democratic capitalism, and they have it. At the same time, no one wants to go back to the unregulated robber-baron era of 1890, it’s all just a question of where on that regulatory spectrum we should be. There are different opinions and different answers to that, but by painting a picture of a good vs evil dichotomy, all discussion is shut down and progress ceases.”
Tim Miller could not have said it better!
Nancy Mace has turned into one of the most disgusting human beings ever. As a woman, I am ashamed of her.
He scared them, they know they won’t win without the young voters and they love him. Not to mention he speaks in coherent sentences.
You've got to find something to do to keep yourself engaged. It can be small. It has to be sustainable of course. It can't consume your whole life. But we've all got to find a way to pick away at this hateful, awful nonsense. The alternative is to ignore it or become overwhelmed, and neither of those will get us through.
Thanks Tim and Sam. You guys are the voices that will keep us engaged to stop this lawless shit for brains felon and his Nazi's.
It’s Trump’s MO - post something, and if it’s popular, turn it into policy. If it’s unpopular, take it to an extreme and then make it a policy.
thanks. stay on this, guys.
One thing we can do is boycott Avelo Airlines. This airline accepted a 150 million $ contract to take part in operating deportation flights out of airports in the U.S. Go to StopAvelo.org to see if your airports in your state fly Avelo and you can take part in a protest. I'll be going to a protest at the Portland International Airport here in Maine tomorrow.
As always thanks for distilling it all down for us, guys. I know the immigration stories are hitting you both hard but consider giving some coverage on yet another one. And it’s close to home , Tim. Donna in New Orleans, originally from Iran and in the country for almost 50 years. Married with an adult daughter and allowed to stay with supervision. Snatched out of her garden. Fuck these guys!
Sam &Tim, Thanks for the reporting and commentary. Nothing better than letting out a therapeutic fuck you, assholes. Tim, your great leadoff hitter. These hate mongers will do anything to drive the divide deeper. We should defend anyone or anything that's attacked by the likes of them. And what can be said of Nancy Mace? She is twice divorced and made a sexual assault charge in congress but not anywhere else. She condemned Jan. 6th but did not vote to impeach. She makes a noise every once in a while to try to stay relevant. She went to a Military College so maybe we should hook her up with Hegseth and a couple fifths of Jack. I can feel it coming on...Fuck you! Assholes!
Way to go Robert. Nancy Mace? what the hell has she accomplished in congress? Another brain dead maga with a microphone. The shit for brains voters would elect a beaver to office.
Stephen Miller has talked about creating a “de-naturalization” committee/agency. We are just 6 months in, I believe that is coming. The criteria for removing citizenship could be anything from ever having broken the law, not convicted mind you, just accused to being a registered democrat.
The people in this country are getting to be really deplorable. I am in despair.
BG, do not despair. When you have people like Tim and Sam, we will always have hope.
These people make me want to pull my white skin off. What the absolute fuck. I’m so disgusted.
You guys are the best. I just got back from China and we are making that country's human rights and rule of law look better all the time.
SCOTUS just put us a step closer to tossing the Constitution.
Yeah and what will happen to them then. Don't believe they ever think about that.
Some might continue to be employed by the Cheeto Dusted TACO!🌮
No, I really believe that if things end up with trashing our Constitution, those with pitch forks will head for the ass hole 6.
Can we ask anti-American clowns like Mace who are against the constitution be deported to maybe South Sudan? Why not give it a go?
What would happen if someone called ICE on Mrs Vance or Mrs Trump?
I'd be happy to place that call!
They're trying to gin up the murderers in the base hoping someone will go after Zohran.
This is what I thought.
What??? Whhy the F do they care about a NYC mayoral race? This HAS TO STOP!
Sam- I too am outraged about the lack of coverage of these kidnappings. Please answer me why it is that every democrat is not playing these horrific videos on the floor of the capital so they can bring attention to everyone, but also to force Republicans to answer to this. Why isn't Booker and his colleagues holding down the floor for hours playing these horrific images???
I love how Bukwark gets corrected to Borg when Sam says it.😀
Shut my mouth and call me stupid but I surely did not see this coming! wtf? Deportation is the answer to everything. Don’t like a US citizen? Exile! I’m grateful to y’all for making me aware of these outrages, but I’m really depressed.
Trump goons up to their usual hateful behavior.
And, on when you guys are on MSM yell just as loudly about this even if not asked...My senators are not standing up
Maybe deport Trump --
Tim: you were a liberal arts major??? Ha! How did you get to Jeb's campaign?
I had to laugh out loud at the end! I don’t do math, either. As a reading specialist, I do ABC’s, not 1,2,3’s. 😂
Tim, how do you really feel ? (I love it. Tell it like it is.)
Thanks for calling out this overt racism, Sam and Tim. We appreciate you. Stay strong. 💪
Thanks for this post - I’ll forward and hope and pray it isn’t seen as prescient in the future as I fear it may be. Appreciate you both
I don’t know if you’ve seen this.
A Soldotna man Francisco Rodriguez-Rincon was taken by ICE to Tacoma, Washington on May 21 and won’t return him to Alaska for trial. This first story was June 11.
https://www.adn.com/alaska-news/crime-courts/2025/06/11/soldotna-restaurant-owner-detained-by-ice-in-washington-state-despite-alaska-judges-order-releasing-him-from-custody/
This second story has more details about Mr. Rodriguez-Rincon and was June 23.
https://www.adn.com/opinions/2025/06/23/opinion-why-are-we-deporting-a-man-who-became-part-of-our-community-and-helped-build-the-soldotna-economy/
This third story is about immigration detainees being brought to Alaska. June 9.
https://www.adn.com/alaska-news/2025/06/09/alaska-jails-holding-40-immigration-detainees-from-outside-under-deal-with-ice/
For every one Carol there’s ten Franciscos.
Go off Tim! Love the energy.
Yes! These harsh words are exactly what these people deserve.
So there are echoes from the Pax Americana past of the US disapproving of a very left leaning Iranian: Mosaddegh. He was the democratically elected PM of Iran from 1951-53 who ushered in (gasp)“socialist” reforms like social security, higher taxes including land taxes, and the nationalization of Iranian oil. (taken from British petrol interests). The guy was very progressive for the time. BUT…the UK and the US, threatened by his removal of oil interests, helped the internal overthrow via coup and installed the Shah….who was a brutal dictator and later overthrown in the…1979 Islamic Revolution. R-klans today are suffering Reptilian brain ancestral vitriol towards an educated, progressive Muslim Indian-American naturalized citizen who suggests that NYC can do better than just have a mayor who professes a hatred of rats and collects kickbacks from the highest bidder….
Sigh. Quoting Santayana seems appropriate about now.
"Those who do not remember history are doomed to repeat it."
Not only is this performance by Mace and Ogles for the base, and not only a precursor for what the government can do in the future, (deportation of immigrants) but it also leads to political violence incited by these idiotic morons.
Unfortunately, I am "represented" by Andy Ogles. Why does he possibly care about the New York City Mayor's race? What is his opinion about the Medicaid cuts for his citizens? Perhaps, there aren't any. Deplorable!
I don't agree with Tim here on Theo. He might feel bad but then he's yucking it up with JD Vance about Frederick Douglas being gay. I just hope one day this unabashed racists go away for good.
even liberal arts mathematicians can figure it out! this is BAD, y’all!
Seriously WTF? Where are our representatives in government and why aren’t they pitching a fit? Old, sad question I know, but seriously 🤬
Hard to do while buried waist deep up the Dear Rapist's ass.
These comments ARE from our representatives in government.
Not the ones I voted for
Have to say I love the Bulwark guys. I am thankful, deeply thankful for independent journalism. I especially love that they help me laugh in these dark days as they report on the truth of what is happening.
Keep the passion coming (when you have the energy, of course). Sam's point it so relevant: it's impossible to keep up. So frightening. This is more than I feared, and I feared a lot.
Tim & Sam are my comfort content and Tim is absolutely right it is not a joke. Thank you for speaking the truth
Wow - thanks for covering this. Whenever I think nothing will surprise me anymore, it’s stories like this that show that going numb is not an option.
The Thomas case was under Obama. It’s actually very clear under the law that he’s not a citizen. You are not automatically a citizen at birth (outside of the US) if your father is a citizen. He needs to meet certain requirements that his father, a naturalized citizen, did not meet under the law.
Thomas had a green card. He could have naturalized. He didn’t. He was charged with a crime. That can make you deportable. In 2013, he was issued a notice to appear because they intended to deport him.
Don’t get wrong — the law needs correction here. This is ridiculous for someone like him.
But this is 100% legal, initiated by the Obama admin.
Nancy Mace seems extremely unhinged, in addition to being a gross creep.
And to think, once I thought she was one of the better ones of the horrible crew of GOP in Congress.
It was an easy mistake to make! Lol
These fucking assholes! Fuck these people! I must say either of these phrases 10x/day. Add a few fucking wankers in there.
Exactly
People who are afraid and narrow-minded will come up with any sort of outrageous arguments to justify their own warped world views.....
These are the sort of people that are the instigators of racial hate - they should be prosecuted......
Thanks, Sam and Tim. I agree with you both 100% that we MUST keep calling out the horror. Every single time.
I'm with Tim on this - just came from seeing my friend become a naturalized citizen, along with 98 others. It was inspiring. Nancy Mace and that other bag of dicks can go fuck themselves!
Keep up the outrage!
A joke? When did rethuglicans develop a sense of humor? Tim’s right. Fuck these people.
EVERYONE of us needs to call all this shit out on a regular basis. Silence = Violence.
Greetings, Comrade Tim and Comrade Sam! But seriously, thank you for speaking out about this. So messed up.
I love Tim Miller! Keep bringing the truth!
I'm laughing with you. They are disgusting.
Let's be clear here: racist jokes are STILL racist. full stop
“Well, at least we can retire that faded and false line, ‘antisemitism has no place in New York City.’”
This wasn’t some current racist member of the GOP conference, this is noted “fair-minded” intellectual David Frum.
Those Islamophobic roots run deep in the neo-cons.
Then deport Elon and Melania! So fing hypocritical!
Something just came to me about Mamdani being Muslim and the threat to be deported along with the lack of learning from FAFO. This is NOT Mamdani. But I am sick to death of the people who didn’t vote or voted third party because of Palestine, NOT learning anything from this! We wouldn’t be worrying about any of this happening if we had Harris. It was so plain and simple!
It’s not just racist Republicans. Famed never Trumper David Frum boldly announced that NYC now welcomes anti-Semitism.
The call is coming from inside the NT camp, y’all.
Tale as old as time.
Why do congressmen from South Carolina and Tennessee give a crap about who is mayor of NYC? As a Texan, I barely care.
Nancy Mace is a total embarrassment to this state. She jumps on every bandwagon of discrimination that passes her way.
I'm ashamed of her all the way from Raleigh NC. You have my sympathy 🙏🏾
Appreciated. Really hoping that district kicks her out next year.
Omg what is wrong with these people. 🤦🏼♀️
I knew they would pull this bs.