America Mustn’t Push Ukraine Into an Unjust, Unstable Peace
Plus: MTG announces her resignation and what you might have missed this week.
Happy Saturday! Overtime is for everyone. If you’re a Bulwark+ member: thank you. If you’re not, there’s no better time to subscribe to Bulwark+ than today. If you like today’s issue, you can share this newsletter with someone you think would value it.
The U.S. Must Not Push Ukraine Into an Unjust, Unstable Peace
It would be a moral betrayal and a strategic blunder.
by Mark Hertling
THERE’S NO WAY for me to address the reports about an apparent attempt by the Trump administration to launch a new “peace process” for Ukraine without confessing a personal bias.
Years ago, when commanding U.S. Army Europe, I worked closely with the Ukrainian army as they struggled to shed the dead weight of the Soviet military system and build something worthy of their emerging democratic nation. My closest partner in that effort was Colonel-General Henadii Vorobyov—a Ukrainian who had served years in the Soviet Army before his nation gained its independence. He believed, with passionate conviction, that Ukraine should have a capable, modern military grounded in Western values. We spent hours walking training ranges, poring over doctrine and leader-development techniques, and choosing the right soldiers to become part of a new NCO corps and the right junior officers to rise to the top of their command structure. Vorobyov is gone now, having died in 2016, but I think of him often. I imagine how proud he would be if he saw what his soldiers have endured since 2014—and how he might react to what some in Washington now propose for his nation.
Since February 2022, I’ve followed this war every day. Not casually. Not passively. Closely. I’ve watched Ukraine fight for its life in ways that remind me of why nations build armies in the first place: to defend their people, their land, their unique culture, their way of life. I’ve watched Russia shift from attempted blitzkrieg to criminal attrition, from incompetence to brutal strikes against civilians. I’ve traced the arcs of all the phases and campaigns—Kyiv, Kharkiv, Bakhmut, Robotyne, the failed summer offensives, the Black Sea successes—and often written about each phase.
And now, hearing the rumblings of a push toward a new peace initiative, something feels deeply wrong. . . .
ICYMI: Here are links to each newsletter section so you can quickly get back to that edition you may have missed this week.
Morning Shots - Triad - Huddled Masses - Press Pass - Bulwark Goes to Hollywood - The Opposition - False Flag - The Breakdown - Receipts
🚨OVERTIME🚨
Happy Saturday! Wherever you are this upcoming holiday, we here at The Bulwark hope you have a Happy Thanksgiving.
In preparation, here is the latest iteration of The Bulwark Thanksgiving Cookbook. Click the image below to check out recipes from members of the Bulwark community.
I’m away this week on travel, so no links today.
Question prompt: What’s your family’s weirdest Thanksgiving tradition? Mine? If we are out of town on a trip, we eat at the Hard Rock Cafe.
Tech support questions? Email members@thebulwark.com. Questions for me? Respond to this message.
—30—
Editorial photos provided by Getty Images. For full credits, please consult the article.
Trump - Putin - Steve Witcoff (Middle East and Russian envoy) - Ukraine
The story of the money and Kompromat is the story behind the 28 part Ukrainian peace plan, written by Putin demanding de facto Ukrainian surrender and Trump’s pressure on Zelensky.
Trump’s collusion with Russia was not a hoax which was made quite clear from the news conference at Helsinki. Putin still owns Trump…and it shows.
Aside from yet again demonstrating Trump’s total subservience to Vladimir Putin, this latest so-called peace plane (piece plan) demonstrates once again that Trump only has one “negotiations strategy”: making threats/bullying. How many times has Trump tried to bully Ukraine with threats of withholding military aid and recon? Five or six times now by my count. All have been rejected.
Why does Trump always resort to threats? In his black and white world, the strong take from the weak, bribes are signs of affection, lies are proof/justification, and fear is motivation.